Contents
The $2 million Lockheed Martin Navy computing settlement resolved allegations that government employees and contractors steered a Navy support-services award toward the SAIC team. The alleged advantage began before the award, with nonpublic procurement information, earlier access to solicitation information, and terms chosen to favor that team. If you worked on the bid or knew how the solicitation took shape, this is the part of the procurement you would recognize.
The Justice Department announced the Lockheed settlement on January 24, 2011. A former employee of the Navy computing center brought the False Claims Act case. The question at its center was who had helped arrange the competition that produced the government’s contract.
The General Services Administration awarded the task order to Science Applications International Corporation, known as SAIC, in April 2004. It purchased support services for the National Center for Critical Information Processing and Storage at the Naval Oceanographic Major Shared Resource Center at Stennis in Mississippi. The Navy center was the customer the work supported, while the procurement ran through GSA.
SAIC teamed with Lockheed Martin and Applied Enterprise Solutions to perform the work. Here, Lockheed received payment under its subcontract with SAIC, putting the company’s work and money one step below the government award. We see a striking price for resolving allegations of an inside track: Lockheed’s settlement matched the amount the Justice Department said it had received under its subcontract.
That relationship matters to someone who worked inside a teaming partner. The suit tied the alleged steering before the award to false bills sent to the government under the resulting contract. An insider’s view of the bid can therefore reach the government-money question even when the insider’s employer was a subcontractor.
In this case, the alleged red flags in government procurement fraud were unequal access to government information and solicitation choices intended to favor one team. The suit alleged that government employees conspired with SAIC, Lockheed Martin, Applied Enterprise Solutions and its chief executive to secure the task order for the team. The Justice Department described distinct ways of giving the bidders an unequal start:
The alleged steering extended to contract type, which sets payment terms and who carries cost risk. For someone involved in proposal development, that makes the terms the team wanted worth comparing with the government’s eventual solicitation and the bid prepared against it.
We see the unfairness in the allegation plainly: a bidder can be asked to compete against a team that helped tilt the contest, with help from the government’s own people. The government is buying through that contest, and the other bidders are preparing offers against its terms. The alleged inside advantage reaches both the public buyer and the businesses trying to win the work fairly.
A former employee of the Navy computing center brought the qui tam case, and the Lockheed announcement allocated a share of the recovery to that whistleblower. A whistleblower case under the False Claims Act can pay 15% to 30% of what the government recovers.
The investigation involved the Justice Department’s Civil Division, the Defense Criminal Investigative Service, the Naval Criminal Investigative Service and the GSA Office of Inspector General. The United States joined the case against the other defendants but did not join against Lockheed Martin. Lockheed nevertheless reached its own settlement with the United States.
On September 29, 2011, the Justice Department announced separate settlements totaling $22,676,000 with the other defendants. They resolved allegations about the same advance information and solicitation steering.
SAIC agreed to pay $20,400,000 against $116 million in contract receipts reported in that announcement. Applied Enterprise Solutions and its chief executive agreed to pay $2,166,000 together, while the two former government employees agreed to pay $110,000 together.
The government employees named in the case had held the director and deputy director roles at the Navy computing center. The later settlements thus reached both members of the contractor team and people on the government side of the procurement.
For these allegations, the useful evidence connects who received procurement information, when they received it and who shaped the solicitation to the resulting award and payments. We examine procurement communications and contract records together because the alleged advantage began before the government started paying.
Solicitation drafts and dated communications can show how terms developed and when information reached a particular team. Proposal versions and teaming records can connect that access to the companies preparing the offer. The task order, subcontract and payment records then connect the successful bid to the businesses receiving the government’s money. Those are the connections we would examine with someone who knew this procurement from the inside.
In its 2022 report Hidden Costs: US Private Military and Security Companies and the Risks of Corruption and Conflict, Transparency International Defence and Security recommended reporting subcontractors’ identities, ownership and itemized service values, including those beyond the first and second tiers. It also recommended identifying potential subcontractors when bids are submitted.
That recommendation keeps the businesses behind the winning bid in view when the government pays. Here, we would examine which company participated in the procurement decisions and which company’s subcontract carried the resulting payment.
If you saw procurement information reach a favored team or helped prepare a bid against terms someone had arranged from the inside, talk with our whistleblower experts about what you saw. We connect your knowledge of the solicitation and the team to the award and payments, and bring in defense procurement whistleblower lawyers who understand those relationships. We stay beside you as that inside knowledge becomes the foundation of your case.