Contents
In the Level 3 Communications WITS 3 kickback settlement, the telecommunications company agreed to pay $12,772,843 to resolve allegations of subcontractor kickbacks, improperly obtained competitor bid information and false woman-owned small-business representations. The Justice Department announced the resolution on June 25, 2021, covering both Defense Department inspector general work and a separate Department of Homeland Security contract. If you handled the bids, selected the subcontractors or received their invoices, this case reaches decisions you would recognize.
WITS 3 was a General Services Administration contract under which the Defense Department’s Office of Inspector General ordered supplies and services from Level 3. As prime contractor, Level 3 subcontracted work to MSO Tech and P.V.S., two Florida companies the government identified as having the same owner.
The government alleged that in 2012 the subcontractor owner paid kickbacks to senior Level 3 managers to steer work to MSO Tech and P.V.S. In return, the companies allegedly received favorable treatment and subcontracts.
The whistleblower’s complaint described specific benefits behind the subcontracting relationship. It alleged that a company officer received paid hunting trips, a trip to the Daytona 500 and a new pickup truck from the subcontractor owner in exchange for continued awards.
The complaint put the WITS 3 work at roughly $1 million per month for Level 3. It alleged a bargain involving a government official’s son: a job at Level 3 in exchange for renewed business with the Defense Department’s inspector general. According to the whistleblower, a vice president told him to hire the son to work on the Homeland Security contract he managed, with the promised business coming through the separate defense contract.
The complaint traced the son’s résumé through government and company email accounts. When a Level 3 manager forwarded it to the vice president, the manager added:
Well …. His resume is a little thin but he has excellent references.
We read that reference as a comment on who could bring the business back. The complaint alleged that the son was hired, WITS 3 work resumed, and Level 3 issued an MSO Tech purchase order and added a markup to the subcontractor’s bill.
The complaint also alleged that the son lacked the required security clearance, leaving other employees to do his work while he received his full salary. It said the government was billed and paid for his work during periods when there was no work he could perform.
The government alleged that a Level 3 senior manager knowingly obtained protected competitor bid information to gain an advantage in bidding on WITS 3 task orders. An employee who saw how that information arrived could explain an advantage invisible on the face of the bid.
A similar allegation appears in the whistleblower complaint against ADS Tactical. There, the whistleblower alleged that a contracting officer supplied precise rival bid amounts, allowing ADS to bid just below its competitors. The complaint also alleged that the company deliberately passed on enough bids to avoid drawing attention to its wins.
Those allegations show why the communications behind an offer matter in government procurement bid-rigging cases. A losing bidder may see only a lower price, while someone inside the winning company may know where the price came from. In the WITS 3 case, the government specifically identified access to protected competitor information as the alleged bidding advantage.
The Homeland Security Terrawatt allegation concerned who qualified for subcontract work and who actually performed it. The government alleged that in 2011 Level 3 told Homeland Security that P.V.S. qualified as a woman-owned small business to satisfy the contract’s requirement to award a portion of the work to such a business. It alleged that company personnel knew the man who owned MSO Tech also owned and controlled P.V.S., and that MSO Tech performed the work awarded to P.V.S.
The complaint made that small-business representation concrete. It alleged that P.V.S. had no employees, payroll or assets despite receiving millions of dollars in subcontract work. MSO Tech employees allegedly performed both the work and P.V.S.’s billing and back-office functions.
The whistleblower said he knew this because he received the invoices. He described an MSO Tech program manager sending four invoices totaling $1,094,716 from her MSO Tech email address, with instructions to pay P.V.S. The complaint’s description of the paperwork gets to the point:
PVS letterhead was more or less the only link between PVS and this work, because it had no employees, payroll or assets.
A company on the letterhead, another company’s people doing the work. We see the complaint’s absurdity in that split: the government was promised qualifying subcontract work, and allegedly got a change of stationery. The complaint alleged that Level 3 made those representations and certifications four times a year while knowing they were false.
The ownership question also matters beyond this case. In its 2022 report on private military and security companies, Transparency International Defence and Security described how obscure subcontractors can conceal the diversion of government funds. It recommended connecting subcontractor identities, their actual owners and the value of their services to the invoices prime contractors submit. Those questions also run through the Terrawatt complaint: who owned the subcontractor, who supplied the labor and who sent the bill.
A former Level 3 employee brought the False Claims Act case that led to the settlement. His complaint identified his role as senior program manager for the Homeland Security contract, placing him at the point where subcontractor invoices and instructions from company management met. That helps explain how he could describe both the paperwork and the people behind it.
The settlement resolved civil claims under the False Claims Act, the Anti-Kickback Act and the Procurement Integrity Act. The Justice Department credited Level 3’s cooperation and a coordinated effort involving the Defense Criminal Investigative Service and Homeland Security’s Office of Inspector General. The announced amount covered the WITS 3 and Terrawatt allegations together.
A whistleblower case under the False Claims Act can pay 15% to 30% of what the government recovers. The program manager’s account shows the kind of inside knowledge a case can draw on: who requested the hire, who sent the invoice, and what the company told its government customer.
The useful evidence connects the company’s representation to the government purchase. In the WITS 3 allegations, that means the task-order bid, the protected information and the subcontract decisions. In the Terrawatt allegations, it means the business named in the subcontracting representation, the people who performed the work and the invoices submitted for it.
The complaint’s invoice example shows why the employee receiving a bill may understand something the letterhead conceals. In his account, the sender worked for one company, the payment instruction named another, and the prime reported qualifying subcontract work to the government. We work with insiders to connect those details to the contract, the money and the decisions behind the claim.
If the subcontractor on the paperwork differs from the people you dealt with, or you saw a supplier’s favors influence an award, speak to one of our Whistleblower Experts about the subcontracting decisions you witnessed. We build the case with you and bring in defense contractor whistleblower lawyers who understand procurement, kickbacks and subcontracting representations. From the first conversation through the pursuit of a recovery, we stay on your side of the table.