Crane Company: The Navy Valve Settlement Over Unapproved Materials

Whistleblower Justice Network

In the Crane Navy valve settlement, Crane Company agreed to pay more than $4.5 million to resolve allegations that it supplied military shipbuilders with butterfly valves containing unapproved reinforced-Teflon seats and Monel bolting. A former site quality manager brought the whistleblower case, and her complaint described the details a testing or manufacturing employee would recognize: stiff valve seats heated before testing, returned valves given new identities, and certificates allegedly unsupported by test records.

The Justice Department announced the civil settlement on October 6, 2021. The government alleged that Crane used unapproved materials and failed to disclose the changes to the Navy. The broader complaint shows how a nonconforming defense product can acquire paperwork that tells the buyer a different story.

What the Crane Navy Valve Settlement Covered

The government alleged that Crane supplied high-performance butterfly valves with unapproved reinforced-Teflon seats from May 2011 through September 2017 and unapproved Monel bolting from May 2011 through September 2015. The valves went to military shipbuilders for use in Navy ships. Crane allegedly sold them as military-specification valves while failing to disclose the component changes required by the Qualified Products List program.

The Qualified Products List identified approved valves under military specification Mil-V-24624. As the complaint explains, qualification covered the listed product and manufacturing facility, and changes to the product or manufacturing process had to be reported to the Navy. A listing for an approved valve did not give Crane approval for undisclosed changes to its materials.

The complaint described an internal memorandum acknowledging sales of military-specification valves with reinforced-Teflon seats instead of the approved material. It also identified customer bills of materials calling for those seats and alleged that Crane filled the orders without reporting the change to Naval Sea Systems Command. That puts the customer’s request, Crane’s own knowledge and the Navy’s approval in the same frame. A customer asking for a particular seat did not answer the approval question.

Heating the Seat to Change the Test

The whistleblower alleged that Crane used an unapproved testing method to try to make stiff valve seats pass. After a customer returned valves that failed testing, the complaint said engineers suspected the rigid reinforced-Teflon seat material and tried heating it:

As a result, Crane engineers soaked the seats of several of the valves in a hot water bath at 145° for an hour before each test. The engineers hoped this would “soften” the stiff seat material enough to produce a passing result.

United States ex rel. Jacobson v. Crane Co., whistleblower complaint, paragraph 45

The complaint said the method did not produce reliable results. Its allegation concerned a change to the conditions under which the valve was tested, as well as the material inside it. We call that changing the test to suit the valve.

The whistleblower also alleged a later incident in which engineers used a toaster oven to heat seats after machinists could not get a batch of valves through testing. According to the complaint, a machinist brought the concern to the quality manager, who alleged that those seats were placed in valves and shipped to fill orders. That account gives the testing concern a connection to delivered goods, beyond what happened at the test bench.

New Tags, New Serial Numbers, the Same Valves

The complaint alleged that W&O, a Crane customer, returned FlowSeal valves and asked Crane to retag them as military-specification valves. Crane allegedly changed the tags, assigned new serial numbers and issued certified materials test reports saying the valves met military testing requirements. The whistleblower said the valves themselves still did not match the approved configuration.

That mismatch extended beyond the body material named on the replacement tag. According to the complaint, compliance would also have required changes to the disc, seat, packing, bearing and actuator. The alleged shortcut changed the product’s identity on paper while leaving those component differences unresolved.

The new serial numbers created another problem. The complaint alleged that their prefix identified Crane’s Chihuahua factory in Mexico, while the military qualification covered production at Conroe, Texas. The whistleblower said the reassignment destroyed traceability, leaving the valves’ true source unverifiable.

The Certificate Needed a Test Behind It

The whistleblower alleged that Crane reissued test certificates without supporting test documentation after working on the returned valves. Her complaint said some valves had components replaced and passed tests, but Crane never determined the cause of the failures or investigated further to prevent them from recurring. It then allegedly issued certificates for the returned valves stating that they passed the required shell and seat tests.

For a quality employee, that is a specific break in the record: a certificate reports a result, but the documentation behind that result is missing. The complaint connects the return, the replacement component, the testing and the certificate sent back with the valve. We examine those records together because a passing statement at the end can conceal what happened along the way.

How the Valve Record Reached Navy Money

The complaint alleged that the government paid Crane or reimbursed prime contractors in reliance on Crane’s representations and certificates. The industry structure matters here: the prime contractor sells directly to the government, while suppliers and distributors can provide the components underneath that contract. A valve manufacturer’s paperwork can reach the government through the shipbuilder’s purchase and payment records.

The same connection appeared in Bradken’s naval-steel case. The government alleged that falsified strength and toughness tests concealed nonconforming steel and caused shipbuilders to bill the Navy as though the steel complied. Under its separate criminal deferred prosecution agreement, Bradken admitted the government’s allegations. The path is the same: a supplier’s test report becomes a shipbuilder’s bill to the Navy.

The Crane whistleblower also alleged a competitive cost: manufacturers following the military specifications and qualification requirements would be disadvantaged by suppliers that did not. That gives the material and testing requirements a commercial consequence as well as a quality purpose. The honest supplier has to deliver the approved product at its price.

What Evidence Is Needed to Prove Fraud?

For the valve allegations, the relevant evidence connects the approved configuration to the actual component, its test history and the representation used for payment. The complaint makes that comparison concrete through bills of materials, customer returns, tags, serial numbers and certified materials test reports. Each answers a different part of what the customer received and what the customer was told.

The former site quality manager could describe problems across manufacturing, testing and documentation. A machinist’s account of a heated seat and an engineer’s knowledge of an approved material may explain a discrepancy that the final certificate conceals. We work with that product knowledge and the records behind it to establish how the discrepancy reached a government purchase.

The Whistleblower Case and Civil Resolution

The former employee brought a False Claims Act qui tam case, and the settlement resolved claims from that case. The Justice Department’s Civil Division and the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of Texas coordinated the case, with investigative support from the Defense Criminal Investigative Service and the U.S. Navy Criminal Investigation Division.

The announcement also provided for the former employee to receive a share of the settlement. A whistleblower case under the False Claims Act can pay 15% to 30% of what the government recovers. For someone who knows the difference between an approved valve and the one shipped, that is a reason to talk with us about what the plant records show.

You Know What Changed Inside the Valve

If you know which material changed, how a test was altered or why a valve received a new identity, talk with our whistleblower experts about the Navy purchases behind it. We build the case with you and bring in defense contractor whistleblower lawyers who understand product specifications, testing and the government’s payment. We stay beside you as your knowledge of the plant becomes the evidence behind the claim.

WHISTLEBLOWER JUSTICE NETWORK CAN HELP YOU
Make a difference.
Whistleblower Justice NetworkReport Fraud
100% CONFIDENTIALFREE CONSULTATION24 / 7 / 365