Contents
Defense contractor time charging fraud uses false hours or false descriptions of work to bill the government for labor it did not receive. You may know which aircraft the crew maintained, which ship it worked on or who was away when the time sheet says otherwise. That knowledge connects the charge on a screen to the work behind it. We follow the time record, the instructions and the government’s bill with you. The paid labor category and the worker’s actual qualifications or wages are examined in Underqualified Labor on Defense Contracts: Resumes, Labor Categories, and Billed Rates and False Certified Payroll on Defense Construction: The Wages Promised and the Wages Paid.
Labor mischarging cases reach from small entries on military-engine purchase orders to inspections that allegedly never happened. They also reach beyond payroll: a maintenance assignment, a leave record or a crew’s daily log can contradict what the company charged.
A labor charge represents that someone performed work, that the work belonged to the contract charged and, where the contract requires it, that the worker met the billed labor category. The time sheet, job code and payroll each tell part of that story.
The contract explains how the hours become money. Cost-reimbursement contracts pay allowable incurred costs within the contract’s limits. Under a time-and-materials contract, qualifying hours are billed at fixed labor-category rates that include wages, overhead and profit. A false hour can therefore carry more than the employee’s wage into the invoice.
The labor trail can begin at a subcontractor. The prime contracts with the government, while its suppliers work under subcontracts and purchase orders. An employee who knows the supplier’s actual assignment can help explain a charge that reaches the government through the prime.
False labor billing can invent time or claim a task was completed when it was not. The CDI, Boeing and Huntington Ingalls cases show how those allegations appear in ordinary working records, from purchase-order allocations to maintenance charges and dive operations.
CDI Corporation agreed to a $1.95 million settlement announced in November 2010 over alleged false labor charges on military aircraft-engine work under General Electric subcontracts. The government alleged that CDI’s Sharonville office directed allocations to purchase orders for work never performed on those projects. The entries were half an hour or less, allegedly concealing the charges in small increments.
That is a recognizable problem for someone who knows the engineering assignment and the purchase order. We look at what the employee worked on, what the entry said and how that entry reached the customer’s bill.
Defense contract time charged to meetings, not maintenance, was central to the allegations in Boeing’s San Antonio C-17 case. The government alleged that maintenance contracts absorbed mechanics’ meeting time and other labor not properly chargeable to those contracts. Boeing paid $23 million to resolve those allegations in 2014.
The allegation that a military contractor billed time during extended breaks arose in a separate case involving Boeing’s Long Beach Depot Center. The government alleged that extended breaks and lunch periods went onto Air Force C-17 maintenance and repair charges. Boeing paid $18 million in that settlement, announced in 2015.
We see the same question behind both Boeing settlements: what work did the government actually buy? A mechanic or supervisor can explain the assignment behind an entry that accounting sees only as hours against a contract.
The government alleged that Huntington Ingalls Industries’ predecessors billed for underwater ship-hull inspections that did not occur as claimed. Huntington Ingalls also disclosed the dive-billing problem. Its civil resolution announced in August 2017 required a new $7.9 million payment and also covered allegations of labor shifted between Navy and Coast Guard shipbuilding contracts.
For the inspection allegation, the task itself supplies the comparison: the dive operation claimed and the work actually performed. For the allocation allegation, the comparison is between the ship receiving the work and the ship charged.
Attendance and leave records can expose hours attributed to people who were elsewhere. The MPRI and L-3 cases show why the comparison has to follow the particular employee through the billed period.
Defense contractor billing leave as deployed labor was the alleged mechanism in MPRI’s Army support case in Afghanistan. The government alleged that MPRI billed Army labor for employees on leave outside the country from March 2005 through October 2010. MPRI agreed to a $3.2 million settlement announced in February 2014.
The whistleblower had worked as a finance officer and contract support official in Afghanistan. The relevant connection ran through personnel deployment records, leave records and billed labor. Someone in finance could see the charge, while the personnel record explained where the employee was.
L-3 Communications allegedly billed processing hours that exceeded each person’s attendance at a deployment center. The government alleged that the company calculated each person’s time using the earliest arrival or latest departure of anyone at the replacement center that day. The allegations concerned Fort Benning and Fort Bliss before overseas aviation support.
L-3 agreed to a $4.63 million settlement announced in September 2015. A former independent contractor brought the whistleblower case. We see the absurdity in that alleged formula: someone else’s attendance became your billable time.
Cross-charging moves the cost of work onto a contract that did not receive it. AEPTEC Microsystems allegedly shifted labor from fixed-price work for commercial purchasers and other government entities onto Navy cost-plus-fixed-fee contracts. Its settlement announced in April 2006 addressed that change in who carried the bill.
The incentive follows the payment terms. On firm-fixed-price work, the contractor bears the effect of actual costs on profit or loss. Moving labor into reimbursable work can transfer that burden to taxpayers. When a cost also enters an indirect pool or a labor rate that duplicates it, the accounting trail extends beyond the individual job code.
Even the same ship can carry different charging arrangements. In the Fairbanks Morse Engine case, supervisory hours included in a fixed-price engine-repair subcontract were allegedly moved to a separate time-and-materials subcontract on the USS Ashland. The company disclosed the conduct, corrected it and repaid overcharges before an additional civil settlement.
If your concern is that a defense contractor manager changes employee charge codes, we can examine the instructions behind the entries with you. The whistleblower complaint against Huntington Ingalls alleged that supervisors instructed crews to use hull numbers unrelated to their actual work:
The Ingalls supervisors named in paragraphs below ordered subordinates on a daily basis to write down, on “Daily Time Log” documents purporting to describe accurately the work of a particular foreman’s crew during a particular day, four-digit “hull” numbers without regard to whether or not the work to be done that day as to those items or orders was in fact done on (or as to) the actual hull represented by that four-digit number.
The complaint alleged that false hull and order allocations concealed exceeded hourly targets and protected incentive payments to the company and bonuses to managers. It also alleged that the resulting Force Reports supplied the hours used to prepare government invoices. In that account, the crew’s work, the supervisor’s instruction and the incentive bill were parts of the same decision. The ship did not change. The paperwork did.
The evidence connects the labor claimed, the work actually performed, the government’s bill and what the people directing the charge knew. We examine those connections with you, using the contract or purchase order, time records, task assignments and payment requests.
The original timecard and any later version help us understand what changed. If your concern involves an edit or approval, we examine who made it, who approved the charge and which billed period it reached. Attendance, deployment and leave records show whether the person was there. Maintenance and inspection records show the task claimed. Payroll and the job code connect that employee’s time to the charged work.
A government voucher can hide the individual detail. The Defense Department’s inspector general described that problem in its Semiannual Report to the Congress for April through September 2018, discussing an audit of Army logistics support in Afghanistan:
Specifically, the contractor provided supporting documentation for labor, employee travel, and employee bonuses that presented costs for hundreds of employees as a single sum for only one employee.
The audit also identified direct labor costs for employees not physically present in Afghanistan. The report treated the costs as unsupported and described shortcomings in the Army’s examination of vouchers. For an insider, the practical point is the detail lost between the employee record and the total presented for payment. We follow the charge back to the person, assignment and period it supposedly represents.
A knowingly false labor charge can support a case under the False Claims Act. The link to government money can run through a prime contractor’s bill, a reimbursement voucher or an incentive-payment calculation. We examine both the false entry and the information available to the people responsible for it. Under its agreement resolving a criminal investigation, Northrop Grumman Systems Corporation admitted billing practices on an Air Force communications program that included leisure time charged as work.
A whistleblower case under the False Claims Act can pay 15% to 30% of what the government recovers. If your concern includes protection after questioning labor charges, we work through that with you and defense contractor whistleblower lawyers. If you entered the hours under a supervisor’s direction, talk with us about that instruction and your role.
If you know why the billed hours differ from the work, speak to one of our Whistleblower Experts about the charge and the instructions behind it. We turn your knowledge of the crew, the task and the time records into your strongest defense contractor whistleblower case, bringing in defense contractor whistleblower lawyers who understand labor billing. We stay with you from that first discrepancy through the work of pursuing the case.