GS Engineering: The Lease, the Charge and the Army Monitor

Whistleblower Justice Network

GS Engineering, its president and a former bookkeeper agreed to pay a total of $1 million to resolve government allegations over lease costs charged to defense contracts. Alongside the civil payment, the resolution included a three-year Army administrative agreement and a corporate ethics monitor. The Justice Department announced the resolution involving GS Engineering, its president and a former bookkeeper on September 13, 2019.

For someone handling intercompany charges on defense contracts, the case puts a familiar expense at the center of the government’s bill. The government’s allegation concerned the lease costs passed between related businesses. We want to understand both sides: the business receiving the rent and the contractor asking taxpayers to cover it.

How a Lease Cost Reaches a Defense Contract

The Justice Department alleged that GS Engineering charged defense agencies twice for the same data acquisition equipment. Between August 2009 and December 2015, the company allegedly fully depreciated the equipment and charged that depreciation to government contracts, then purported to transfer the equipment to an affiliated business and lease it back. The later lease charge put the equipment back into the government’s costs after its depreciation had already been charged.

The government also alleged that companies under common control leased real property and equipment to GS Engineering at rates above the allowable amounts between January 2009 and November 2016. Those allegations concern both the equipment’s prior cost history and the amount claimed for the later lease. The lease invoice needs to be read beside the asset ledger and the payment terms of the defense contract.

The government’s cost-allowability rule requires supporting records showing that claimed costs were incurred and belong to the contract. It also requires reasonable costs, compliance with the contract’s terms and the applicable accounting rules. We examine the lease expense against those requirements, including the basis for charging it to the government’s work.

A contractor can pay an invoice and record it in its books while leaving the central question unanswered: why should taxpayers bear this cost? The reasonableness rule gives no automatic presumption of reasonableness to an expense just because the contractor incurred it. We care about the government’s bill, not simply whether money moved between the companies.

The Lease Amount and the Allocation Are Different Questions

For a lease inquiry, we examine the space or equipment being paid for alongside the work that used it. The government’s allocation rule connects a cost to the benefit received or another fair relationship. The invoice amount and the portion charged to a defense contract each need an explanation. Charging an expense to the wrong work can move the burden from the business that benefited to the government customer.

A shared lease expense can enter an indirect-cost pool and spread across several contracts through the allocation. Same rent, several government bills. For reimbursable work, provisional billing rates anticipate final rates based on actual annual costs. We compare the annual cost proposal with the earlier billings to understand where the charge went and how much reached the government.

Why the Business Behind the Invoice Matters

A related-company lease requires looking at both sides of the transaction. We want to understand the business receiving the rent, the business charging the government and who controlled the decisions between them. The GS Engineering allegations concerned lease costs across that relationship, making the intercompany records part of the payment story.

Research on private military and security companies illustrates why following money beyond the prime contractor matters. Transparency International Defence and Security put the visibility problem sharply in its 2022 report Hidden Costs:

The lack of information on subcontractors obscures potential conflicts of interest in the subcontractor supply chain and conceals the true extent to which PMSCs receive US Government funding as subcontractors.

Hidden Costs: US Private Military and Security Companies and the Risks of Corruption and Conflict, Transparency International Defence and Security, 2022

For an intercompany cost inquiry, we take that visibility problem seriously: the government’s contracting relationship can show less than the records inside the businesses receiving the money. An insider who understands both sides of a lease can help connect the expense to the charge the government sees.

What Evidence Is Needed to Prove Fraud?

The useful evidence connects the lease charge, the records behind it, the government payment request and the decisions that put the charge there. We examine the original records and the submitted account with you, comparing the agreement, invoices, allocations and billing with what you know happened inside the business.

The president and former bookkeeper were among the participants in the GS Engineering civil resolution. In assessing a lease-cost case, we examine who approved the expense, who assigned it to the work and who understood how it would reach the government.

A bookkeeper may know how an invoice entered the ledger. A manager may know why the arrangement was approved, while someone in contract billing may know how the expense appeared in the payment request. The person working with the leased space or equipment may understand which job actually used it. Those perspectives help connect a familiar business expense to the representation made for government payment.

The Army Agreement and Ethics Monitor

The GS Engineering resolution went beyond a civil payment to Army oversight. Its president and former bookkeeper also accepted voluntary exclusions from government contracting. We would judge the value of a monitor by what changes in the decisions behind the charges: which expenses get challenged, who can approve them and what reaches the government.

A 2022 study in the International Journal of Management and Humanities found higher average penalties among defense contractors with compliance and ethics programs, but the difference was not statistically significant. That comparison does not tell a billing insider whether a program works. We look for the answer in how lease expenses are reviewed, approved and carried into government billings.

Another Lease Case Put Purchase Costs Beside Rental Charges

Macalan Group, formerly NEK Advanced Securities, agreed to a civil payment of $2.08 million to resolve allegations that included equipment lease charges exceeding purchase costs. The Justice Department announced the settlement on September 16, 2013. The government alleged excessive or unallowable costs under a Joint Improvised Explosive Device Defeat Organization contract supporting teams in Iraq and Afghanistan.

That separate case gives an equipment-billing insider a concrete comparison: what the equipment cost and what the government was charged to lease it. The acquisition record can explain something a rental invoice alone leaves out. We want both in view when the alleged rent exceeds the price of buying the gear.

A whistleblower case under the False Claims Act can pay 15% to 30% of what the government recovers. If you know how a lease charge was chosen and why it reached a defense contract, that knowledge gives our experts a concrete starting point for assessing a whistleblower case over the government’s bill.

When You Know How the Rent Became the Bill

If you have seen lease charges reach a defense contract through an intercompany invoice or allocation you understand, speak with our Whistleblower Experts about how that rent became the government’s bill. We build your strongest defense contractor whistleblower case around your knowledge of the accounting and the decisions behind the charges, and bring in defense contractor fraud whistleblower lawyers who know cost-billing cases. We stay beside you as the case develops, with your knowledge of the business at the center of the work.

WHISTLEBLOWER JUSTICE NETWORK CAN HELP YOU
Make a difference.
Whistleblower Justice NetworkReport Fraud
100% CONFIDENTIALFREE CONSULTATION24 / 7 / 365