Contents
In the CDM Smith and CDM Federal settlement, the companies agreed to pay approximately $5.6 million to resolve allegations of inaccurate certified cost or pricing data submitted to the Navy. The government alleged that the companies submitted inaccurate cost and labor-hour estimates and related certifications for architect-engineering task orders at Navy bases. For an estimator or project employee, the important connection is between the labor information inside the business and the figures it gives the Navy.
The Justice Department announced the civil settlement on August 31, 2020. It named CDM Smith Inc., headquartered in Boston, and CDM Federal Programs Corporation, located in Fairfax, and said the agreement resolved a False Claims Act case brought by a former CDM employee, along with other civil claims.
The Justice Department alleged that CDM gave the Navy inaccurate estimates and certifications while negotiating prices for architect-engineering work. It said the alleged conduct would violate the Truth in Negotiations Act, which requires truthful, accurate and complete cost and pricing data in certain government contract negotiations.
For someone who prepares those estimates, the underlying facts matter as much as the finished proposal. The pricing-data certificate says the data were accurate, complete and up to date when the price was agreed. That includes the facts behind an estimate and reasonably available information elsewhere in the company, even if the negotiator did not personally know it.
That makes the estimator’s view and the negotiator’s view part of the same pricing question. An employee may know which information fed the labor estimate or whether the proposal used an older set of inputs. The employee’s contribution is explaining what the company knew when it put those numbers before the Navy.
The contract’s payment terms connect that pricing information to government money. We trace the disputed estimate to the particular work being purchased and the price the government agreed to pay, so the case rests on the transaction the employee recognizes. While the allegations against CDM concerned estimates used to negotiate prices, a separate complaint against Huntington Ingalls Industries alleged that hours assigned to the wrong hulls supported Navy and Coast Guard incentive payments.
A separate defense pricing audit shows how ordinary purchasing records can expose a problem in certified data. The Department of Defense Office of Inspector General’s Semiannual Report to the Congress for April through September 2018 describes a Defense Contract Audit Agency recommendation for a $26.7 million price adjustment. The audit concerned a contractor’s failure to submit current, accurate and complete cost or pricing data.
The auditors identified inaccurate information about agreed supplier prices, firm quotes, updated offers and parts ordered before certification. Those records showed what the business had already negotiated or ordered when it certified its data.
The timing is the point an estimating employee would recognize: did the proposal reflect the information already available inside the company? A dated supplier offer and a dated certification can tell different stories about the same purchase. A purchasing employee may recognize an updated offer that never reached the proposal team; an estimator may know which version the team used. We connect that inside knowledge to the price the government was asked to accept.
For a Navy pricing case, useful evidence connects the company’s cost information to its proposal, certification and government payment. We line up what the Navy was told with the cost information inside the business and the government’s money.
An estimating employee may understand the factual inputs behind the labor projection. A purchasing employee may recognize that a newer supplier offer existed before certification. A project employee may understand the work represented by an hours figure. We bring that knowledge into the comparison between the information the business held and the representation it made to the government.
A whistleblower case under the False Claims Act can pay 15% to 30% of what the government recovers. For someone considering a defense contractor whistleblower claim, we bring pricing expertise to the case and stay beside them as it moves forward.
If you saw labor or cost information that did not match a Navy proposal, speak to one of our Whistleblower Experts about what went into the estimate. We work with you to build your strongest defense contractor whistleblower case around that difference and bring in defense contractor whistleblower lawyers who understand pricing disclosures and engineering-service contracts. We stay beside you through the pursuit of a government recovery.