Nolin Rural Electric: Savings That Were an Extra Charge

Whistleblower Justice Network

The Nolin Rural Electric settlement included a $2,619,333 civil agreement resolving allegations of improper Fort Knox energy-project bills, gas overcharges and payments for a former Army official’s job. That civil amount sat beside an energy-project program cumulatively valued at approximately $270 million. If you know which project incurred a cost and which project carried the bill, you know the distinction at the center of this case.

The Justice Department’s April 13, 2015 announcement identified the company as Nolin Rural Electric Cooperative Corporation of Elizabethtown, Kentucky. Its work for Fort Knox involved energy-saving projects whose projected savings were supposed to cover their costs. The announcement says that, as part of the civil settlement and non-prosecution agreement, Nolin and the United States agreed to the relevant facts in Appendix A to the non-prosecution agreement.

Fort Knox Bought Projects That Were Supposed to Pay for Themselves

Nolin and Fort Knox entered a Utility Energy Service Contract in 1996. Each energy-saving project was called an Energy Conservation Opportunity, or ECO, and Fort Knox awarded Nolin 108 of them. The design was straightforward: each project’s projected savings would offset its cost.

That made the project authorization and savings calculation central to the government’s spending decision. An ECO identified approved work, while a pro forma presented the expected project economics. For someone handling these projects, the contract’s payment terms connect the work, the promised savings and the bill that reaches the Army.

Unapproved Projects Billed Under Approved Ones

The Justice Department’s account of the agreed facts describes Nolin charging Fort Knox for unauthorized work by putting the costs under unrelated approved ECOs. The waste-to-energy and solar projects show the same accounting maneuver. A project number on an invoice can hide which project actually generated the expense.

Waste-to-Energy Expenses Went Through Another Project

According to the government’s account, Nolin billed Fort Knox $199,020 in early 2010 for work and expenses associated with a proposed waste-to-energy project that was never approved for implementation. The announcement says Nolin submitted the expenses under another, unrelated ECO that had been approved. The release reported $398,040 in double damages recovered through the civil settlement for those unauthorized expenses.

The cost mischarging lay in where the expenses were sent for payment. An employee familiar with the proposed waste-to-energy work could connect an expense to that proposal even when the bill named a different project. We see an approval doing double duty: permission for one project became the way to bill for another the Army had never approved.

Solar Costs Were Spread Across Approved Projects

The announcement says the 2010 Sample Solar Panel Project was never authorized or approved by the Fort Knox contracting officer. Nolin nevertheless billed its $94,178 in costs under three unrelated, previously authorized ECOs. The civil settlement included $12,394, described as double damages on Nolin’s profits from that work.

Here, the employee’s knowledge of the solar work could connect charges scattered across different approved projects. The relevant comparison is between the work described in the underlying expense and the work the charged ECO authorized. The final total alone would miss the routing described in the government’s account.

A similar mismatch appeared in the Fairbanks Morse Engine settlement. The government alleged that supervisory hours included in a fixed-price engine-repair subcontract for USS Ashland were shifted to a separate time-and-materials subcontract on the same ship. The company disclosed the conduct, corrected it and repaid overcharges before agreeing to an additional civil settlement. In both cases, the physical work can stay the same while the contractor changes how the government is asked to pay for it.

Gas Charges Above the Contract Rate

The government’s account of the natural-gas billing described an extra charge on authorized work. The gas ECOs allowed Nolin to extract natural gas from Fort Knox land and bill Fort Knox at a specified rate. The government said Nolin billed above that rate by adding an amount it characterized as retained savings.

Those additional charges amounted to $800,089, which Nolin agreed to credit to Fort Knox as part of the civil settlement. For a utility-billing insider, the comparison is between the rate the ECO permitted and the calculation behind the submitted bill. We would want to understand who added the retained-savings charge and how the amount reached the Army’s account.

The label deserves attention because savings were the reason for the energy program in the first place. In that account, retained savings described an additional charge to the Army above the authorized gas rate. Calling it savings did not make the government’s bill smaller.

Savings on Paper, Losses in the Projections

According to the Justice Department’s account of the facts agreed under Nolin’s non-prosecution agreement, the company understood that the Army required every ECO to pay for itself within ten years. Between 2002 and May 2008, Nolin presented pro formas for twenty proposed projects that gave the impression they met that requirement and would save more than $7 million over ten years. The government’s account said those same projects were actually projected to lose more than $15 million over that period.

That comparison goes directly to why the projects received approval. According to the release, none met the ten-year payback requirement, yet they generated more than $8 million in payments to Nolin.

For an insider who prepared or reviewed those calculations, the assumptions and revisions behind the pro forma matter. We compare the expected costs and savings with the version used to obtain approval, then connect that decision to the resulting payments. A program sold on paying for itself needs more than an attractive savings column.

The Defense Contractor Job and the Ethics Condition

The civil settlement also covered Nolin’s hiring of a former Fort Knox Energy Program Manager as its Resource Energy Manager. The ECO funding that position required compliance with the Joint Ethics Regulations, which incorporated the ethics laws the former official was accused of violating. The Justice Department’s announcement described conflict-of-interest and wire-fraud charges concerning his actions in both the Army and contractor roles. It announced $1,408,810 in double damages, twice the amount Nolin received to pay him in that position.

Fort Knox Could Not Support the Energy Savings

The Justice Department’s account of a September 8, 2014 Defense Department inspector general audit said Fort Knox officials had not properly awarded and administered the energy-project task orders. Officials also could not support claims that the projects achieved their projected energy savings. The audit found that inadequate internal controls increased the risk of fraud, waste and abuse. Separately, the Defense Criminal Investigative Service’s Dayton Resident Agency conducted the investigation, supported by the Defense Contract Audit Agency and Army Criminal Investigations Command.

The savings question matters after approval as well as before it. In its semiannual report covering April through September 2018, the Defense Department inspector general described a separate review of Defense Logistics Agency energy savings performance contracts. That review identified $2.7 million in questionable contract payments across three projects, involving undocumented validation of claimed savings and an unresolved disagreement about whether savings were sufficiently supported.

That later review concerned a different contract program. It gives an energy-project insider a concrete comparison: the savings used to justify a project and the savings supported during performance are separate questions. Someone who understands the calculations can explain what the approval and payment records leave unanswered.

What Evidence Is Needed to Prove Fraud?

For these allegations, useful evidence connects the project authorization, the work performed, the savings representation and the government’s bill. We work with insiders to make those connections through project and payment records, including ECO approvals, underlying expenses, pro formas, invoices, rate calculations and credits. Your knowledge can explain why a charge appeared where it did or why the savings presentation changed.

The different records answer different questions. An approval identifies the authorized work, an expense record identifies the work that generated the cost, and the bill shows where the company sought payment. For the employment component, the job arrangement and its funding connect a personnel decision to government money. We build the account around those decisions and the people who understood them.

A whistleblower case under the False Claims Act can pay 15% to 30% of what the government recovers. If your work gives you a view into project charges or savings claims that the government’s paperwork obscures, our whistleblower experts can assess that knowledge with you as the foundation for a defense contractor whistleblower case.

You Know Which Project Carried the Charge

If you saw unapproved work billed through another project or savings figures that concealed projected losses, tell our whistleblower experts what happened inside the project. We build your case with you around the costs, approvals and decisions you know, and bring in defense contractor fraud whistleblower lawyers who understand project billing and procurement conflicts. We stay beside you as the case moves from your knowledge of the work to the government’s claim for recovery.

WHISTLEBLOWER JUSTICE NETWORK CAN HELP YOU
Make a difference.
Whistleblower Justice NetworkReport Fraud
100% CONFIDENTIALFREE CONSULTATION24 / 7 / 365