Sikorsky: The Army’s Case Over Withheld Parts Prices

Whistleblower Justice Network

In the Sikorsky Black Hawk spare-parts settlement, Sikorsky Aircraft Corporation agreed to pay $3.5 million to resolve allegations that it withheld lower parts prices from the Army during negotiations. For someone who worked in purchasing or pricing, the question at the heart of the case is familiar: what did the company know about its costs, and what did it let the customer see?

The U.S. Attorney’s Office for the District of Connecticut’s March 31, 2014 announcement described a civil settlement under the False Claims Act. Sikorsky, based in Stratford, Connecticut, manufactured Black Hawk helicopters and their spare parts for the U.S. military and friendly nations.

What the Army Alleged About Black Hawk Spare Parts

The government alleged that Sikorsky failed to disclose accurate, complete and current cost and pricing data from February 7, 2008 through September 8, 2011. The buyer was the Army Aviation and Missile Life Cycle Management Command, one of the Army commands responsible for purchasing Black Hawk spare parts.

The allegation was specific: when prices for the government were being determined, Sikorsky had lower prices for certain parts and failed to disclose them. The government said that omission caused it to pay artificially excessive prices. In explaining the case, the Justice Department pointed to the Truth in Negotiations Act’s requirement to disclose that data during negotiation.

Failure to disclose accurate, complete and current cost and pricing data created an uneven playing field in the negotiation process which tilted unfairly in Sikorsky’s favor.

U.S. Attorney’s Office, District of Connecticut, March 31, 2014

Why Cost Data Matters Before a Price Is Agreed

Cost information can shape what the government agrees to pay before a contractor delivers anything. In fixed-price contracting, the initial negotiation can depend on the contractor’s cost information, and the price can be corrected later if that information was wrong. The relevant comparison is between the facts available when the price was agreed and the facts disclosed to the government.

That puts a pricing employee’s knowledge in a different place from the final bill. The useful evidence may sit in the material used to prepare the negotiation: what a part would cost, when that information became available and whether it reached the buyer. In the Sikorsky allegations, the missing information was lower parts prices already available to the company during the pricing process.

For an insider, the timing gives the discrepancy its meaning. A dated lower price, the disclosure that accompanied the proposal and the price agreed with the Army can explain how the government’s negotiating position was affected. We examine those connections together, including who knew the pricing information and what the government was told.

Who Investigated the Sikorsky Pricing Allegations?

The Sikorsky pricing investigation involved the Defense Criminal Investigative Service, the Defense Contract Audit Agency, the Department of Defense Office of Inspector General’s Audit Division and the Defense Contract Management Agency. The Black Hawk repair work was principally performed at an Army depot in Texas.

A Defense Department inspector-general report adds a concrete account of efforts to recover money from Sikorsky for depot-support pricing. Its Semiannual Report to the Congress for April through September 2018 lists a September 8, 2011 audit examining how pricing and escalation issues weakened the effectiveness of the Army’s contract with Sikorsky to support that depot.

The entry called for refunds from the contractor for pricing and excessive escalation. It reported that Army Contracting Command at Redstone Arsenal was pursuing money back from Sikorsky on parts covered by a Defense Contract Audit Agency audit report. The unfinished action was the audit’s refund recommendation, not a report on whether the civil settlement had been paid.

Separate Sikorsky Settlements Concerned Testing and Markups

Sikorsky agreed to pay $2,941,000 in the separate Black Hawk armor-testing settlement announced in 2009. The government alleged that, from 1991 through 2006, Sikorsky installed armored plates beside pilots and copilots without the required ballistic testing. Ceradyne Corporation supplied the plates. The evidence question there concerned whether the protective plates had undergone the tests the Army required.

Sikorsky Support Services and Derco agreed to pay $70 million in their settlement announced in 2024 over parts for Navy trainer aircraft and markups between affiliated subcontractors. The government alleged that Sikorsky Support Services sought reimbursement without disclosing an illegal subcontract under which it bought parts from Derco at supplier cost plus a fixed 32% markup. A former Derco employee brought the whistleblower case.

That allegation followed the markup into the Navy’s reimbursement request. The Black Hawk spare-parts pricing case followed withheld cost information into an Army negotiation.

What Proof Do You Need as a Whistleblower?

For a parts-pricing matter, the useful proof connects information available inside the company to what the government was told and what it agreed to pay. We assess the pricing and contract records alongside your knowledge of how the parts were purchased and how the disclosure was prepared.

Purchasing, pricing and contract-administration employees may each see a different part of that comparison. One may understand the lower available price, another the data furnished to the Army, and another the agreed price for the parts supporting repair work. We work with the person who understands that difference to build the connection between the company’s knowledge and the government’s money.

A whistleblower case under the False Claims Act can pay 15% to 30% of what the government recovers. Our work on defense contractor whistleblower claims starts with the specific representation, the records behind it and your knowledge of the business.

You Know What the Parts Really Cost

If you saw lower parts prices kept out of government negotiations, talk with our whistleblower experts about the pricing decisions you witnessed. We build the case with your knowledge of the purchasing process and bring in defense procurement whistleblower lawyers who understand cost disclosures and negotiated prices. You have a partner in us from the first conversation through the pursuit of the government’s recovery.

WHISTLEBLOWER JUSTICE NETWORK CAN HELP YOU
Make a difference.
Whistleblower Justice NetworkReport Fraud
100% CONFIDENTIALFREE CONSULTATION24 / 7 / 365