Contents
Contents
In the Tareen Dermatology fraud settlement, the practice, its physician and its CEO agreed to pay $1,630,000 to resolve allegations of false dermatology claims to Medicare and VA-administered programs. The whistleblowers’ complaint went further, describing alleged instructions on a whiteboard and rewards for prescription referrals. For a billing specialist or clinician who knows the difference between the care delivered and the care billed, those details are the story.
The Justice Department announced the settlement on June 28, 2024. Two whistleblowers brought the False Claims Act case, including a former billing specialist. The resolution came from coordinated work by the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the District of Minnesota, the Department of Health and Human Services Office of Inspector General, and the Department of Veterans Affairs.
The government alleged false claims involving Mohs surgeries and services billed as though the physician supervised them on days she was absent from the clinic. The settlement also covered allegations that the defendants inappropriately waived beneficiary copays for office visits and used certain skin grafts in circumstances that did not justify the billing. The graft allegation puts the clinical reason for treatment beside the billing question: what justified using the graft for that patient, and what did the claim say?
The whistleblowers alleged that the physician performed Mohs surgery on government-pay patients but sent the pathology interpretation to an outside party. Patients generally went home while waiting for the results, according to the complaint’s account. The complaint alleged that the physician nevertheless billed codes 17311, 17312 and 17313 instead of the proper code.
The operative note, pathology report and claim describe different parts of the same service. Connecting them shows who performed the surgery, who interpreted the specimen and what work the government was asked to pay for.
The Tareen complaint alleged incident-to billing fraud through missing physician involvement and claims that concealed who actually provided the service. It described three alleged failures: the physician did not initiate treatment for patients seen by physician assistants, was not on site to supervise, and the assistants who provided the services were not identified on CMS Form 1500.
The complaint also alleged that claims continued under the physician’s NPI while she was in Paris in late summer 2021. When a whistleblower questioned the billing, a manager allegedly explained that it paid more and pointed to the physician’s signing and closing the notes. The complaint put the alleged reimbursement increase at 10% to 15%.
The payment incentive follows the billing identity. Physician-supervised incident-to claims can receive the physician allowance, while direct physician-assistant claims generally receive a lower allowance. An employee who knows who saw the patient may therefore know something the claim obscures.
The complaint alleged that staff received instructions to fit diagnoses to payment requirements regardless of the patient’s presentation. Its account of the weekly meetings puts the alleged decision before the claim:
During weekly team “Huddles,” instructions were put on a whiteboard indicating that in order for a certain procedure to be covered, it must correspond to a particular diagnosis — regardless of what the patient actually presented with.
The alleged procedure upcoding was equally specific. The whistleblowers said phototherapy was billed as higher-paying excimer laser treatment, and scraping and cautery procedures were billed as more expensive excisions. They also alleged that the physician billed treatments for alopecia, vitiligo and other noncovered treatment under covered treatment codes.
The complaint described lists around the office showing each insurer’s maximum number of removals. It alleged that the physician maximized biopsies regardless of medical necessity, and that an external audit flagged laser and photochemotherapy billing as 98 to 99% above the expected billing distribution for the peer group.
We see the reversal in the whiteboard allegation. The diagnosis was supposed to describe the patient, yet the alleged instruction started with the procedure that would get paid and worked backward. Someone present at those meetings could explain a decision that the completed claim alone would never show.
The copay allegation concerned a policy allegedly designed to encourage repeat services. According to the complaint, patients were asked to sign hardship forms regardless of their actual financial condition. That allegation gives the paperwork a specific purpose: removing the patient’s payment obligation to encourage another service.
The 2020 Journal of Forensic and Investigative Accounting paper A Forensic Accountant’s Guide to the Most Potent Federal Laws Used Against Healthcare Fraud examines routine copay waivers as an inducement to use a provider. In the whistleblowers’ account, the hardship form served that incentive: take the cost off the patient so the next visit happens.
The complaint also alleged that employees earned an internal currency for steering prescriptions to the practice’s pharmacy. One Tareen Dollar went to an employee for a filled prescription, while an Accutane prescription earned three. Employees could redeem the rewards for cosmetic products and procedures at Tareen Dermatology, including laser therapy and injections. We see the bargain in that allegation: steer prescriptions to the pharmacy, earn treatments at the clinic.
Patients allegedly received dispensary reward certificates too. The complaint further alleged employee bonuses of $1 to $2 for each laser or phototherapy treatment. The alleged incentives reached both the prescription destination and the treatment count, giving an insider a reason to connect reward records with the services billed to government programs.
Skin Cancer & Cosmetic Dermatology Center settled allegations about Mohs procedures billed as though its physician performed both surgery and pathology when someone else performed at least one part. That case puts the same practical question in focus: whose work did the claim represent? The Tareen complaint’s off-site pathology allegation makes the path of the specimen part of that answer.
In its guilty plea, Pain Specialists admitted billing under its physician owner’s NPI while he traveled, for services requiring personal consultation or direct supervision. The Justice Department’s account of the plea shows why travel and staffing records can matter to a claim carrying a physician’s identifier.
The whistleblower’s complaint against Family Dermatology alleged a different form of referral pressure: practices faced a software price increase unless they directed pathology work to a designated laboratory. It alleged that the arrangement steered services paid by Medicare and Medicaid. Alongside Tareen’s alleged pharmacy rewards, that account shows why the financial instruction behind a referral can matter as much as the referral itself.
The people who understand the billing evidence may work at different points in the practice. A clinician knows what treatment occurred, a biller sees the codes and billing identity, and an employee at a team meeting hears the instruction behind them. The Tareen complaint connects those perspectives through the whiteboard, pathology arrangements, travel, hardship forms and rewards.
The 2017 Journal of AHIMA article Busting Bad Medicine: A Call to Action Addressing Healthcare, Fraud, Waste, and Abuse emphasizes comparing treatment dates, treatment descriptions and signatures with the patient’s record, then finding witnesses who can explain what happened. Your knowledge of healthcare billing can expose what the paperwork hides. Our whistleblower experts build the case with you, connecting the claims to the people who can explain the decisions behind them.
A whistleblower case under the False Claims Act can pay a reward of 15% to 30% of what the government recovers. If you recognize the gap between a dermatology service and its bill, speak to our whistleblower experts. We shape the case with you and bring in health care whistleblower lawyers who know dermatology billing.
If you saw a diagnosis chosen for payment, a physician’s identifier used during an absence or rewards tied to treatment, tell our whistleblower experts what happened inside the practice. We build the case with you, bring in physician billing fraud whistleblower lawyers who understand the clinical and payment records, and stay beside you through the pursuit of a recovery.