Brooklyn Patient Medicare Kickback Plea: Cash in a Small Room at the Clinic

Whistleblower Justice Network

The Brooklyn patient Medicare kickback plea concerned cash paid to a patient for receiving services at Solstice Wellness Center. In its October 22, 2010 announcement of the guilty plea, the Justice Department reported that the patient admitted receiving the money in a small room at the clinic, from a man he identified as one of its owners. For someone who saw patients paid, visits counted or claims submitted, the case connects a transaction inside the clinic to services billed to Medicare.

Solstice was a Brooklyn-area clinic purportedly providing physical therapy and diagnostic services. The case involved kickbacks paid to a patient, while the criminal complaint described a former medical provider supplying a ledger to investigators.

What Are Kickbacks in Health Care?

In this case, the kickbacks were cash payments to a patient in exchange for purportedly receiving clinic services that, the criminal complaint alleged, were then billed to Medicare. The patient pleaded guilty to conspiring to solicit and receive those payments. The exchange tied money handed over inside the clinic to business charged to a public health care program.

At the plea hearing, the patient admitted that from approximately January 2009 to April 2010 he visited Solstice for medical services and received cash for those services. He also described where the payments happened and identified the payer as an owner. Those details give an insider something concrete to recognize: the place, the person handing over money and the visits connected to it.

We see a clinic paying its own patient, with Medicare on the other side of the bill. The alleged arrangement made taxpayers the customer for care the clinic paid its own patient to receive.

The Ledger Recorded Names and Visits

The Justice Department’s account of the criminal complaint says a former Solstice medical provider gave law enforcement a ledger containing Medicare beneficiaries’ names and an indication of their numbers of clinic visits. The patient who pleaded guilty was among the beneficiaries listed. That makes the ledger a record of attendance to compare with the patient’s account of receiving cash. A clinic worker who recognizes the entries may understand how attendance was recorded, while someone who saw the payments may know what happened in the room.

The 2017 Journal of AHIMA article Busting Bad Medicine: A Call to Action Addressing Healthcare, Fraud, Waste, and Abuse describes the value of comparing treatment dates, services and clinical signatures in a patient’s record. It also explains why a person who understands those records matters:

Fraud examiners and investigators will not just stop at documentation alone. They will ask for trustworthy witnesses who can tell them what they know about the fraud.

Busting Bad Medicine: A Call to Action Addressing Healthcare, Fraud, Waste, and Abuse, Journal of AHIMA, 2017

That observation fits the Solstice evidence. Names and visit counts give the account something to connect to, while the admission explains the cash exchange that attendance figures alone would leave unexplained.

One Medicare Number Across Many Providers

The criminal complaint described 124 medical providers billing approximately $214,516 in services to Medicare under one patient’s beneficiary number during a six-year period. One patient, that many providers. The question for someone who knows the clinics is what happened at the visits behind those bills.

The complaint characterized him as an overutilized beneficiary, meaning someone apparently shared among providers and receiving an excessive volume of services. For an insider, that wider billing pattern raises a question about how the same patient moved through the system. Answering it means connecting particular claims to the visits, the care and the people receiving money.

The most useful physician billing evidence makes those connections visible. A visit ledger, a treatment record and a payment account can describe different parts of the same business, and understanding how they fit is where knowledge of the clinic becomes valuable.

Who Commits Health Care Fraud?

A patient can participate in health care fraud, as the Solstice guilty plea shows. A provider can also supply evidence about what happened inside a clinic, as the complaint’s ledger account describes.

The civil whistleblower case involving BioTek reMEDys shows another role: former employees bringing allegations about the business they knew. The government alleged that BioTek routinely waived patient copayments without determining financial need and provided gifts and free practice support in exchange for physician referrals. In its settlement announcement, the Justice Department said the company and its chief executive agreed to pay $20 million, with a $4 million whistleblower reward for the former employees.

Their complaint put the alleged patient inducement inside the billing system. It described instructions to create the appearance of collection efforts before writing balances off:

In many instances, Biotek employees were instructed to falsely make entries next to each unpaid balance in CPR+ to make it appear as though the Pharmacies attempted three collection efforts before writing off the balance. In reality, no collection efforts were made.

Whistleblowers’ allegation, United States ex rel. Wyatt v. BioTek reMEDys, Inc., complaint, paragraph 73

Here, the allegation turned on employees knowing that the collection history on the screen did not match what the pharmacy had done. At Solstice, the patient admitted the inducement was cash.

What You Saw Inside the Clinic

Someone who handled visit records may know how beneficiaries were counted. Someone who dealt with billing may know which services reached Medicare, while a person who witnessed the cash exchange may know who paid and why. We work with that knowledge to connect the arrangement to the government claims it generated.

A whistleblower case under the False Claims Act can pay 15% to 30% of what the government recovers. If you are considering reporting physician practice fraud, our whistleblower experts can build on your firsthand knowledge and bring in healthcare fraud whistleblower lawyers who understand patient inducements and Medicare billing.

You Know What Happened Beyond the Visit Record

If you saw cash passed to patients or billing records made to conceal an inducement, tell our whistleblower experts what happened inside the clinic. We work beside you to build your strongest Medicare kickback whistleblower case around the visits, payments and claims you know, and bring in whistleblower lawyers who understand patient inducements.

WHISTLEBLOWER JUSTICE NETWORK CAN HELP YOU
Make a difference.
Whistleblower Justice NetworkReport Fraud
100% CONFIDENTIALFREE CONSULTATION24 / 7 / 365