Contents
Contents
In the Brooklyn colorectal surgeon billing fraud case, patients told insurers their doctor had billed for surgeries he never performed. The Justice Department’s account of the criminal trial describes what followed: insurers investigated, the surgeon asked patients to certify the surgeries in writing, and patients testified against the bills. For someone inside a practice, the telling detail is what happened after the insurer started asking questions.
The surgeon owned and operated Colon and Rectal Care of New York P.C. According to the trial evidence described by the Justice Department, he billed Medicare and private insurers for surgeries and medical services he never provided from January 2008 to January 2010. This physician billing fraud reached beyond the submitted claim into the practice’s records, correspondence and response to patients who challenged it.
Private insurers began investigating after patients complained about claims for surgeries they had not received, according to the criminal trial testimony. The complaints included billed hemorrhoidectomies, operations to remove hemorrhoids. The patients’ accounts gave insurers a way to test the claims against the care those patients actually experienced.
Medicare scrutiny also focused on the billing pattern. The Justice Department’s announcement of the criminal charges said the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services began investigating repeated claims for multiple hemorrhoidectomies, office visits and examinations on the same day for the same patient. A patient’s complaint and a pattern in claim data pointed toward the same underlying question: what work had the practice actually done?
The Justice Department’s trial account identifies the FBI, the Department of Health and Human Services Office of Inspector General, the New York State Office of Medicaid Inspector General and the New York State Department of Financial Services, Criminal Investigative Division as the investigators. The patients’ complaints and the practice’s own records became evidence in a criminal case against the surgeon.
The criminal charging announcement described both services never provided and follow-up care billed as treatment of unrelated conditions. Those are different ways of making the claim say more than the encounter supports. In the first, a surgery appears on the bill although it did not happen. In the second, the practice presents related care as separately payable work.
According to the court documents summarized in that announcement, the surgeon submitted claims for office visits, examinations and subsequent hemorrhoidectomies as though he were treating distinct conditions. The government alleged that he was actually providing follow-up services related to the initial procedure. That is why the connection between encounters matters: a billing line can conceal that the work belongs with care already provided.
The same payment issue appears in unbundling physician procedures. The clinical record must explain the separate work represented by the additional charge. For a coder or clinician, the useful comparison is the treatment described in the record against the separation asserted on the claim.
In a separate civil case, Skyline Urology agreed to pay $1,850,000 to resolve allegations that it billed Medicare for routine visit services already included in same-day procedures. The Justice Department’s settlement announcement described the alleged use of Modifier 25 to obtain that extra payment. The parallel is the additional charge for care the procedure payment already covered, a distinction an employee who knows the encounter can recognize.
After two insurers confronted the surgeon about complaints of surgeries that never happened, he sent patients letters asking them to falsely certify that they had received those surgeries. The Justice Department described those requests as evidence presented at the criminal trial. The request came after the challenge to the bill, making the practice’s response part of the evidence too.
We see the absurdity in asking the patient to supply the surgery the bill already claimed. For an employee who saw those letters prepared or handled the insurer correspondence, the response to the inquiry could explain something the original claim alone could not: how the practice tried to support the billing once someone questioned it.
That makes the original treatment record and the later certification request worth considering together. One describes the care recorded at the time. The other asks the patient to affirm a version of events after an insurer has objected. The sequence connects the disputed payment to a decision inside the practice.
Eleven patients testified at the criminal trial that they had not received the surgeries and medical services billed to their insurers. The Justice Department also reported that the surgeon’s medical records, including letters to referring doctors, did not support his extensive billings. The case therefore joined patient testimony to a mismatch within the practice’s own healthcare records.
The Journal of AHIMA article Busting Bad Medicine: A Call to Action Addressing Healthcare, Fraud, Waste, and Abuse, published in 2017, explains why documentation and witnesses belong together. It describes checking the treatment date, type of care and clinician’s signature, then makes the point that a chart is only part of the inquiry:
Fraud examiners and investigators will not just stop at documentation alone. They will ask for trustworthy witnesses who can tell them what they know about the fraud.
That observation fits this case closely. The patients described the care they received, while the treatment records and referring-doctor letters supplied written accounts to compare with the claims. Someone inside the practice may understand how those accounts were created and why they diverged.
On June 13, 2012, a federal jury in Brooklyn found the surgeon guilty of one count of health care fraud and five counts of health care false statements. The Justice Department’s later announcement described the trial evidence about unperformed services, unsupported records and the patient letters.
The indictment alleged more than $22.6 million in false claims submitted to Medicare and private insurers and more than $9 million received on those claims. They show why the payment trail matters alongside the clinical one: the false surgery was also a demand for insurers’ money, including Medicare funds.
For a case involving surgeries never performed, the useful evidence connects the claim to the actual encounter and the people who shaped its written account. Here, patients’ accounts, medical records, referring-doctor letters, insurer inquiries and later certification requests supplied different views of the same billed services. A biller may know what went to the insurer, while clinical staff may know what happened during the visit.
If you saw someone request a signature for care that did not happen, or describe routine follow-up work as a separate service, we want to understand what you saw and how it reached the bill. Our whistleblower experts work with you on the connection between that knowledge, the practice’s decisions and the government money at stake. A civil whistleblower case under the False Claims Act can pay 15% to 30% of what the government recovers.
If the surgery on the claim never happened, or you saw the practice ask patients to sign a different story, tell our whistleblower experts about the billing you know. We build the case with you, find physician billing fraud whistleblower lawyers who understand the clinical and payment evidence, and stay beside you through the pursuit of a recovery.