National Spine and Pain Centers: The 2019 Billing and Urine-Test Settlement

Whistleblower Justice Network

National Spine and Pain Centers and Physical Medicine Associates agreed to pay approximately $3.3 million in a 2019 fraud settlement over alleged false physician billing and unnecessary urine drug testing. A former Physical Medicine Associates physician assistant brought the case, describing a practice where the person doing the work, the supervision recorded in the chart and the service billed to the government allegedly told different stories.

What the Settlement Covered

The Justice Department announced the civil settlement on April 25, 2019. The two companies had pain management clinics in northern Virginia, Glen Allen and Fredericksburg, and the former physician assistant brought the False Claims Act qui tam case in the Eastern District of Virginia.

The government alleged that physician-assistant and nurse-practitioner services were billed as though physicians had performed them. It also alleged that urine-test claims violated the Stark Law’s self-referral rules or the Anti-Kickback Statute, and that the defendants ordered medically unnecessary urine drug tests. The allegations reached Medicare and other federal health care programs.

The whistleblower’s complaint describes Physical Medicine Associates as a practice operator doing business under the National Spine & Pain Centers name. Its account takes those billing categories inside the clinics: instructions to clinicians, supervision checkboxes, repeat test orders and incentives to collect more samples.

An assistant U.S. attorney investigated the case. The settlement announcement credits a coordinated effort by the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Eastern District of Virginia, the Department of Health and Human Services Office of Inspector General, the U.S. Office of Personnel Management Office of the Inspector General, and the Defense Criminal Investigative Service Office of Inspector General.

What Constitutes Fraud When Billing Incident To?

The incident-to billing fraud allegation here was that management directed nonphysician practitioners to bill under an ordering physician’s name and NPI regardless of who was present. The complaint alleged that staff received that instruction even when no physician was in the office, and that the practitioners did not receive their own Medicare provider numbers because all their services went under the ordering physician’s identity.

The complaint put a price on that billing identity. It alleged that the practice sought 100% of the physician fee-schedule rate instead of the 85% rate for the nonphysician practitioner’s work. In office billing, the schedule, treatment note, actual practitioner and physician’s involvement help explain what the claim represents. A co-signature alone does not supply the supervision behind it.

The whistleblower also described a checkbox in the electronic patient note for recording whether a supervising physician was present. According to the complaint, management turned that factual question into an instruction:

National Spine instructed the mid-level providers to always check the box stating that a supervising physician was present regardless of whether such a physician was present or not.

United States of America ex rel. O’Connor v. National Spine and Pain Centers, LLC, et al., complaint, paragraph 76

In the whistleblower’s account, we see a record of who was present turned into a record of what management wanted the chart to say. The complaint also alleged that practitioners raised concerns in corporate meetings and were again instructed to bill under the ordering physician.

When One Urine Sample Became Two Tests

The unnecessary urine drug testing allegation followed the same sample from an office screen to an outside laboratory. The complaint alleged that, after a twelve-panel qualitative screen, a medical assistant sent the urine away for quantitative testing of the same drug classes, plus nicotine. The repeat orders allegedly included drugs the patient did not report taking and for which the office result was negative.

The former physician assistant estimated that the Fredericksburg office alone administered approximately 400 in-house screens and ordered 400 duplicative quantitative tests per month. That estimate captured the workflow the whistleblower described: the first test led to another order even when its result supplied no reason to repeat the testing. The initial result, the outside order and the reason entered in the chart are different parts of that story.

A separate case against Coastal Spine and Pain ended in a $7.4 million settlement announced in August 2016 over allegations of unnecessary drug screening. The government said a review of claims data found that every qualitative test billed had a corresponding quantitative test billed, and alleged that Coastal performed the second test regardless of the first result. The payment pattern drew the Justice Department’s attention there. In the National Spine case, a clinician’s complaint described what happened to the sample inside the office.

The Incentive Behind the Test Order

The complaint tied the repeated testing to employee compensation. It alleged that offices competed on volume, with a reward system described this way:

National Spine rewards the office that administers the highest volume of drug tests each week with gift cards, cash prizes, and free meals at restaurants.

United States of America ex rel. O’Connor v. National Spine and Pain Centers, LLC, et al., complaint, paragraph 126

The whistleblower alleged that management also withheld bonuses from the Fredericksburg office manager and medical assistants when the office’s urine-collection rate was 60% in fall 2012. In that account, the pressure reached the staff collecting specimens, not just the clinician ordering a test. A patient’s need for another test was competing with the office’s chance to win dinner.

A test result cannot tell us who profits from the referral. The Journal of Forensic and Investigative Accounting‘s 2020 review of healthcare fraud laws distinguishes Stark’s focus on physician financial relationships from the Anti-Kickback Statute’s focus on payments or other value used to induce referrals. That is why we examine compensation alongside test orders and claims.

The Refill Visit and the Higher Code

The complaint alleged that monthly opioid-refill visits generated more opportunities to bill for office services and drug tests. It described a $15 penalty if a patient sought a refill before an appointment. The alleged pressure therefore reached patients as well as staff: another prescription meant another trip back to the practice.

The same complaint alleged upcoding of the refill visits. It said the low-complexity visits should have been billed under 99213, but management instructed practitioners to use 99214, the code for moderate-complexity decision-making. For a coder or clinician, that alleged instruction connects what happened during the appointment to the higher service level sent to the payer.

The complaint also described a change that depended on who paid. It alleged that, after Medicare began refusing payment for monthly opioid visits on medical-necessity grounds, the practice changed Medicare patients’ required visits to every 90 days. Monthly visits allegedly continued for patients covered by TRICARE, the Federal Employees Health Benefits Program and the Federal Employees’ Compensation Program. The payer-specific instructions are part of what an insider could know beyond the individual claim.

What Evidence Does a Whistleblower Need?

We work with you to connect the records that should agree but do not to the government claims and the instructions behind them. The complaint supplies concrete examples: a physician’s billing identity beside a practitioner schedule, a supervision checkbox beside who was actually present, an outside test order beside the first result, and a higher visit code beside the encounter note. Testing-volume incentives and payer-specific scheduling instructions add the management decisions behind those claims.

That is where a clinician, biller or practice employee’s knowledge matters. A claim can show the billed physician and service, while the person working in the office can explain who treated the patient and why a box, order or code changed. We work with insiders to connect those parts of the account to the government payments at issue.

A whistleblower case under the False Claims Act can pay 15% to 30% of what the government recovers. The former physician assistant’s case shows how knowledge from inside a practice can bring its billing before the government.

You Know What Happened in the Exam Room

If you were told to check a supervision box, repeat a urine test or raise a visit code, speak with our whistleblower experts about the instructions you received. We work beside you to build the physician-practice fraud case and bring in physician billing fraud whistleblower lawyers who understand how clinical work becomes a government claim. You bring the view from inside the practice; we bring the judgment and partnership to pursue it with you.

WHISTLEBLOWER JUSTICE NETWORK CAN HELP YOU
Make a difference.
Whistleblower Justice NetworkReport Fraud
100% CONFIDENTIALFREE CONSULTATION24 / 7 / 365