Contents
In the HealthEssentials fraud settlement, the former chief executive agreed to pay $1 million and the former chief financial officer $20,000 to resolve allegations of inflated Medicare billing and unnecessary patient assessments. The government alleged that both executives pressured employees to inflate bills despite warnings that doing so would be improper. For someone who saw the instructions behind the claims, that is the heart of this case: who wanted the higher bill, what staff were told to do and whether the patient needed the assessment at all.
HealthEssentials Solutions Inc., based in Louisville, Kentucky, provided primary health care in nursing facilities, assisted living facilities and other settings. It operated from 1998 until it filed for bankruptcy and ceased operations in 2005. The Justice Department announced the former executives’ civil settlements on January 10, 2014.
The government alleged that HealthEssentials billed Medicare for inflated or medically unnecessary services between 1999 and 2004. The upcoding allegation concerned the services represented on the bill. The unnecessary-assessment allegation went back to the decision to assess the patient in the first place.
The Justice Department’s account tied both former executives to pressure on employees to inflate billing, despite advice from attorneys and others that the practice would be improper. It separately alleged that the chief executive pushed special medical assessments without regard to whether patients needed them, solely to increase what HealthEssentials could bill for the visits. He had founded the company and served as its president and board chairman as well as chief executive. The former chief financial officer had also been its senior vice president.
We see the distortion in that alleged purpose: the assessment served the bill, and the patient’s need became incidental. An instruction to perform an assessment solely because it produces more revenue reaches into the care itself. The government was alleging that management pressure shaped both the services and the claims sent to Medicare.
The useful comparison runs through the schedule, the assessment or treatment record, the person who did the work and the service billed. Those records show different parts of the same encounter, which is why an insider’s knowledge of the work can matter as much as the finished claim.
For the HealthEssentials allegations, the distinction between medical necessity and the billed service level matters. A clinician may know why an assessment was ordered and what it added to the patient’s care. A coder or biller may know how that work became a higher charge. A supervisor may know where the instruction originated and what happened when someone questioned it. We connect those accounts to the records behind the physician billing: the assessment, the clinical note, the submitted claim and the instructions that joined them, including what management knew when the claims went out.
A health record can describe an assessment without explaining why management wanted it performed. That is where the person who scheduled, delivered or coded the service can add something the document alone does not say. In the HealthEssentials case, the alleged purpose of the extra assessment was central to the government’s account.
The 2017 Journal of AHIMA article Busting Bad Medicine: a Call to Action Addressing Healthcare, Fraud, Waste, and Abuse describes checking treatment dates, treatment types and clinical signatures. It then makes the case for going beyond the chart:
Fraud examiners and investigators will not just stop at documentation alone. They will ask for trustworthy witnesses who can tell them what they know about the fraud.
Someone who heard the demand for extra assessments may explain why the schedule changed. Someone who raised a billing concern may explain what management had been told. We work with that inside knowledge to connect the care, the direction from management and the Medicare claim.
The whistleblower complaint against Bluestone Physician Services of Florida alleged another version of care organized around expected billing. It described routine monthly visits regardless of patient need, with schedules prepared ahead of time so executives could project revenue. The complaint made the reason for the advance scheduling explicit:
In direct contravention of Medicare mandates, Defendants’ executives expect that providers’ schedules will be completed a month ahead of time so that Defendants can make financial projections based on the estimated number of provider visits.
The whistleblower also alleged that Florida clinicians who challenged higher billing levels were told to use the same codes as clinicians in Minnesota because the patient populations were the same. The parallel is the pressure to make patient encounters meet a financial expectation. HealthEssentials’ alleged special assessments and Bluestone’s alleged monthly scheduling both direct attention to a decision made before the claim reaches the government: why the visit or assessment was being required.
In its March 2008 guilty plea, HealthEssentials admitted submitting false statements to Medicare about services in assisted living facilities, according to the Justice Department’s announcement. The company also entered a civil settlement. The same announcement reports that the former billing director pleaded guilty in May 2011 for her role in the company’s billing scheme.
The later civil settlements addressed the healthcare executives’ alleged roles in the false billing under the False Claims Act. As part of his civil settlement, the former chief executive agreed to exclusion from federally funded health care programs for three years. For an insider, that makes the connection between a management instruction and the resulting claim worth explaining: the government pursued the alleged decisions behind the billing as well as the company’s submissions.
The Justice Department’s Civil Division, Commercial Litigation Branch, and the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Western District of Kentucky handled the case. The Department of Health and Human Services Office of Inspector General and the Federal Bureau of Investigation assisted.
The allegations resolved by the executive settlements arose in part from a qui tam lawsuit brought by two former HealthEssentials employees. The Justice Department announced a joint whistleblower award to them. Their part in the case puts the employee’s view of the operation alongside the government’s account of pressure from management.
A whistleblower case under the False Claims Act can pay 15% to 30% of what the government recovers. For a facility clinician, coder or billing employee, the starting point with us is what you know about the assessment, the charge and the instructions behind them. We build the case around that knowledge, the Medicare money at stake and the people who directed the claims.
If you saw facility assessments driven by billing demands, speak with our whistleblower experts about the instructions you received. We build your case around the care and management decisions you know, bring in physician billing fraud whistleblower lawyers who understand facility services, and stay beside you throughout the case. Your account of why an assessment happened can be the missing connection between a clinical record and the Medicare bill.