Contents
In the Baptist Health System false claims settlement, the Jacksonville-area hospital parent agreed to pay $2.5 million to resolve allegations that neurological misdiagnoses led to unnecessary services and drugs billed to government health care programs. The Justice Department said Baptist placed a physician on administrative leave before telling the government about the alleged misdiagnoses. For an insider who saw the clinical concern reach management, the question is what happened to the claims and payments afterward.
The Justice Department alleged that two neurologists in Baptist Health’s network misdiagnosed patients with neurological disorders, including multiple sclerosis, from September 2009 through October 2011. Those diagnoses allegedly caused Baptist Health to bill for medically unnecessary services. The settlement announcement covered claims for unnecessary drugs as well.
The medical-necessity allegation began with the diagnosis that justified the care. The government connected that diagnosis to the services and drugs billed by the network’s subsidiaries. The former administrator’s complaint, as the government described it, connected the alleged intentional misdiagnoses to unnecessary services, tests and treatments.
The alleged consequences reached the patient as well as the payer. In announcing the settlement, the Justice Department specifically identified the potential for patient harm, and the Office of Personnel Management’s inspector general described a violation of patients’ trust. We see two sides of the same allegation: patients received care on a false clinical premise, and taxpayers picked up the bill.
Baptist Health placed one of the physicians on administrative leave in October 2011, but did not disclose the alleged misdiagnoses to the government until September 2012, according to the Justice Department. For someone involved in the response, what management learned about the care and what it did about the money belong in the same story.
The U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Middle District of Florida added the financial allegation in its fiscal year 2014 collections report. It described the whistleblower as a former administrator of the hospital chain and said she alleged intentional misdiagnoses followed by government billing. It then described her allegation about payments already received:
In addition, she alleged that the defendant hospital chain did not return overpayments it had received as a result of the misdiagnoses, after discovering the neurologist’s scheme.
That is the retained-overpayment allegation behind the disclosure chronology. The whistleblower challenged both the bills arising from the alleged misdiagnoses and the hospital’s handling of the payments after discovery. The doctor went on leave. The money, the whistleblower alleged, stayed put.
An insider may know the later part of that account especially well. Someone involved in a clinical review may know what findings reached management, while someone handling payment reconciliation may know how the affected claims were treated. We connect those accounts because a decision about the physician’s work and a decision about the government’s money can involve different people and different records.
A former Baptist Health administrator brought the qui tam case that initiated the government’s investigation. Her allegations connected the neurologist’s work to the hospital chain’s billing and its response to overpayments. The alleged misconduct involved Medicare, Medicaid, TRICARE and the Federal Employee Health Benefits Program.
The U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Middle District of Florida said it investigated and corroborated her allegations. The administrative role matters here: the allegation reached beyond the examining room to what the hospital did with payments already received.
Inside knowledge has a particular value in a case like this. The 2020 Journal of Forensic and Investigative Accounting article A Forensic Accountant’s Guide to the Most Potent Federal Laws Used Against Healthcare Fraud explains that qui tam cases bring otherwise hard-to-detect conduct to light through inside information and supplement government investigative resources. A claim shows what a provider asked a program to pay. An employee may be able to explain what the provider already knew about the diagnosis behind it.
The Justice Department announced the parent company’s agreement on May 6, 2014. The U.S. Attorney’s Office described the settlement as three times the damages on the most egregious claims and twice the damages on the rest. That comparison gives the payment its meaning: the agreement went beyond returning the money tied to the disputed care.
Florida was allocated $19,024 from the settlement for its Medicaid component. The state had paid some of the Medicaid claims at issue.
The announcement also provided for a whistleblower reward to the former employee who brought the case. A whistleblower case under the False Claims Act can pay 15% to 30% of what the government recovers. We work with insiders to connect their knowledge of the care, billing and management response to the government’s financial stake.
For allegations like these, the useful evidence connects the diagnosis, the treatment, the claim and what the provider learned afterward. Clinical findings explain the basis for care. Service and drug records connect that care to a bill, and payment records identify the government money involved. Review findings and the response to them can explain what happened after the concern became known.
The most revealing part of your account may be the connection between those records. You may have seen a clinical concern passed to administrators, worked on claims affected by that concern, or handled the later payment review. We bring that knowledge into the case alongside the records, so the account explains both how the government paid and what the organization knew about the payments it kept.
If you saw a diagnosis questioned while the claims or payments went unresolved, speak to one of our Whistleblower Experts about the decisions you witnessed. We develop your strongest case with you and bring in physician-practice fraud whistleblower lawyers who understand medical necessity and retained overpayments. From your first account of the concern through the case, we stay beside you as partners.