Coastal Dermatology: Cosmetic Services, Coding and a Data-Led Investigation

Whistleblower Justice Network

The Coastal Dermatology settlement set a $787,814 payment to resolve allegations of cosmetic-service billing and upcoding involving Medicare and TRICARE. If you saw how a cosmetic procedure became a covered claim, or how the billed service exceeded the work performed, you know the part of the story a billing total cannot explain.

The Justice Department announced the settlement on March 17, 2015. Coastal Dermatology, a Jacksonville, Florida practice, and its physician owner settled allegations covering January 1, 2009, through April 2014. The government developed the case through proactive analysis of healthcare reimbursement data, which drew attention to the practice’s lesion-removal billings.

What Coastal Dermatology Was Alleged to Bill

The government alleged that Coastal Dermatology knowingly billed for cosmetic dermatological services that were not medically necessary. It also alleged that the practice billed for services when all Medicare and TRICARE requirements had not been established.

The distinction matters in an office that performs cosmetic work. The Robert Wood Johnson Foundation’s 2008 research synthesis, Physician Self-Referral and Physician-Owned Specialty Facilities, described most cosmetic surgery as office-based and paid for by patients out of pocket. It explained that these payments escape the discounting applied by Medicare and private health plans. That payment distinction gives the allegation its force: the government said cosmetic services had entered the government billing stream.

The higher-reimbursement allegation concerned what the practice charged for the work. The government described upcoding certain bills to receive more than the allowed reimbursement. For an insider who knows the treatment, the relevant comparison is the service performed and documented against the service represented on the claim.

We see the unfairness to taxpayers and patients in the alleged use of public programs to fund cosmetic work. The Health and Human Services inspector general’s office made the public-money point in the announcement: diverting Medicare funds to uncovered voluntary procedures takes resources from necessary care.

How Data Mining Found Coastal Dermatology

Proactive mining of reimbursement data identified Coastal Dermatology as a top biller for skin-lesion removal and removal of inflamed seborrheic keratoses. Among 3,814 TRICARE-participating dermatologists in the South Region, the practice ranked number one for lesion-removal billings.

The ranking gave investigators a place to look. The allegations they ultimately resolved concerned cosmetic care, unmet program requirements and higher-than-appropriate reimbursement. The data showed the billing pattern. Someone who saw the treatment or prepared the bill can help explain the claims behind it.

The Defense Criminal Investigative Service and the Health and Human Services Office of Inspector General were among the investigators named in the announcement. Medicare and TRICARE claims brought civilian and military health care money into the same case. The defense investigators emphasized preserving taxpayer funds intended for service members, their families and military retirees.

What Evidence Does a Whistleblower Need?

For cosmetic-service billing and upcoding, useful evidence connects the submitted claim to the treatment record and the people who can explain how the bill was produced. We examine the procedure described, the reason for coverage, the billed service level and the payer’s requirements for that service date. The schedule, treatment entry and signatures help connect the claim to the actual encounter.

The Journal of AHIMA’s 2017 article Busting Bad Medicine: a Call to Action Addressing Healthcare, Fraud, Waste, and Abuse describes checking treatment dates, treatment types and nurse or physician signatures against the health record. It then makes the point that a billing-data screen cannot supply:

Fraud examiners and investigators will not just stop at documentation alone. They will ask for trustworthy witnesses who can tell them what they know about the fraud.

Busting Bad Medicine: a Call to Action Addressing Healthcare, Fraud, Waste, and Abuse, Journal of AHIMA, 2017

A clinician may understand the reason for treatment, while a billing employee may understand the code selected or changed before submission. We connect those accounts to the same claim. The person who heard a coding instruction can explain a decision that the final bill shows only as a code.

When a Payment Requirement Supplies the Diagnosis

A separate whistleblower complaint involving Tareen Dermatology describes the kind of instruction an insider can identify. The whistleblowers alleged that weekly staff meetings turned coverage requirements into directions about which diagnosis to use:

During weekly team “Huddles,” instructions were put on a whiteboard indicating that in order for a certain procedure to be covered, it must correspond to a particular diagnosis — regardless of what the patient actually presented with.

United States of America, et al., ex rel. Cremin and Polzin v. Tareen Dermatology P.A., et al., whistleblower complaint, paragraph 215

We find that alleged instruction revealing: the payment requirement supplied the diagnosis. The patient’s presentation was pushed aside. For someone who attended such a meeting, the instruction connects the clinical discrepancy to the decision about how to get paid.

Different Ways a Dermatology Case Begins

Coastal Dermatology’s case began with government reimbursement-data analysis. A larger settlement came from the separate Associates in Dermatology case. Former clinic employees brought that qui tam case, which led to a $3 million settlement announced in January 2015. The allegations included an unlicensed medical assistant performing radiation therapy without proper supervision, unnecessary skin-lesion destructions and inadequate documentation.

Those allegations show why the person inside the office matters. A billing comparison can identify concentrated claims, while someone who saw the work may explain who performed it, what supervision existed and whether the treatment record matches the care. The link to government money runs through the particular service and the claim it produced. A whistleblower case under the False Claims Act can pay 15% to 30% of what the government recovers.

You Know What Happened Before the Bill

If you know why a cosmetic service appeared as covered care or who chose a code the treatment could not support, speak to one of our Whistleblower Experts about what you saw. We build your strongest physician billing whistleblower case around that inside knowledge, bring in physician-billing whistleblower counsel and stay beside you as the case moves forward.

WHISTLEBLOWER JUSTICE NETWORK CAN HELP YOU
Make a difference.
Whistleblower Justice NetworkReport Fraud
100% CONFIDENTIALFREE CONSULTATION24 / 7 / 365