Pain MD: Injection Targets and the Owner’s Fraud Verdict

Whistleblower Justice Network

In the Pain MD fraud verdict, a jury convicted the clinic chain’s nonphysician owner on October 24, 2024, of one conspiracy count and 12 health care fraud counts. The Justice Department’s account of the criminal trial described pressure on nurse practitioners and physician assistants to administer unnecessary injections to opioid-dependent patients. For someone inside a pain practice, the case reaches beyond the procedure note to the person demanding more procedures.

Pain MD operated clinics in Tennessee, Virginia and North Carolina. Its pain clinic injection fraud case connected management’s production rankings with the clinical work billed to insurers. The owner did not need to be the clinician holding the needle for his decisions to reach the claim.

Injection Targets Came From Management

The criminal trial account described approximately $35 million billed over approximately eight years, with clinicians ranked by production and pressured to administer unnecessary injections. Pain MD’s reported tendon-origin-insertion injection billing was approximately eight times that of the next highest biller.

The federal court’s February 2022 account of the indictment describes the business behind that pressure. MedManagement was Pain MD’s majority owner, and the defendant owned and ran MedManagement while serving as Pain MD’s president. The nurse practitioners and physician assistant charged with him worked for the management company or Pain MD. The indictment alleged that the owner helped train practitioners to increase productivity through inappropriate care protocols and anatomically incorrect injection procedures.

That relationship matters in a healthcare business where administrative control and clinical work can sit in different entities. In this case, the indictment traced the owner’s role through both the management company and the clinics. Looking only at the clinician’s signature would leave the alleged source of the instructions out of view.

Physician practice billing incentives reach individual services as well as appointments: more services during a visit can increase fee-for-service receipts. The American Medical Association’s report on compensation methods describes physicians receiving combinations of salary, productivity pay and bonuses. For this case, the useful connection is between the activity management measured and the injections clinicians were pressed to deliver. We see a production target reaching all the way into the treatment room.

What Pain MD Told Government Payers

The criminal indictment, as summarized in the court’s order, alleged that Pain MD billed Medicare, TennCare and TRICARE for medically unnecessary tendon-origin-insertion injections into patients’ backs along the spine. It also alleged that some injections were anatomically impossible to perform as recorded in the medical records.

The indictment alleged that Pain MD presented itself as an interventional pain practice offering services intended to reduce reliance on opioids and other narcotic pain medications. Prosecutors alleged that the services instead served to increase revenue and enrich the defendants. We see a grim sales pitch: less reliance on opioids, more unnecessary injections for patients already dependent on them.

According to prosecutors, their medical expert explained why the injections underlying the individual fraud counts were medically unnecessary or medically impossible. The production ranking explains the pressure. The clinical evidence addresses the treatment billed.

What Evidence Does a Whistleblower Need?

For an injection case, the useful evidence in a physician billing case connects the treatment, the claim and the instructions behind both. The court’s order in the owner’s criminal case describes patient records, Medicare claims records and interviews with former employees and patients among the materials prosecutors provided. The criminal trial account adds clinician production rankings. Together, those records reach from a management decision to what happened during the appointment and what the government was asked to pay.

We examine how the patient’s note describes the injection, what service the claim represents and what management expected from the clinician. A nurse practitioner or physician assistant may understand the gap between the documented procedure and the care delivered. The court’s order describes the 1500 claim forms as identifying the patient, provider and services, including the procedure code. A billing employee may understand how the chart’s description became a submitted claim. An employee familiar with the rankings may explain what activity management was trying to increase.

The 2017 Journal of AHIMA article Busting Bad Medicine: a Call to Action Addressing Healthcare, Fraud, Waste, and Abuse recommends checking treatment dates, the type of treatment and the nurse’s or physician’s signature in the health record. It also explains why the person who knows how those records were made matters:

Fraud examiners and investigators will not just stop at documentation alone. They will ask for trustworthy witnesses who can tell them what they know about the fraud.

Busting Bad Medicine: a Call to Action Addressing Healthcare, Fraud, Waste, and Abuse, Journal of AHIMA, 2017

In a practice organized around injection production, that knowledge can explain why the same procedure keeps appearing. The insider’s contribution is the connection between what staff were told to do, what they actually did and what the bill says happened. That is the account we work through with you.

Comprehensive Pain Specialists: Drug Screens Before Patient Evaluation

A separate whistleblower complaint against Comprehensive Pain Specialists illustrates another way management instructions can shape billed care. The whistleblower alleged that the practice required nonclinical staff to order repetitive drug screens before trained medical staff could evaluate whether a patient needed testing. The complaint also described a condition attached to prescription access:

Patients are not allowed to obtain a prescription until they have given a specimen for urine drug screening at their visit.

United States and the State of Tennessee ex rel. Alt, et al. v. Anesthesia Services Associates, PLLC, et al., whistleblower’s complaint, paragraph 150

The same complaint alleged that Medicare was billed for further screens even when staff ignored the results instead of using them in patients’ care. Those allegations show why the practice’s standing instructions belong beside the treatment record. An order can appear routine in a chart while an employee knows the office required it before anyone evaluated the patient.

The Billing Behind the Verdict

The earlier indictment distinguished bills submitted from payments received. As summarized in the court’s order, prosecutors alleged more than $27,537,383 billed to Medicare and approximately $5,054,525 reimbursed.

For a physician practice insider considering a whistleblower case under the False Claims Act, the connection between internal instructions and government claims is central to the work we do together. A whistleblower case under the False Claims Act can pay 15% to 30% of what the government recovers. We assess the billing and the management decisions with you, then bring in physician practice fraud whistleblower lawyers with the experience your evidence calls for.

You Know What the Targets Required

If your practice’s production rankings explain how an injection target became a procedure in a patient’s chart, talk with our whistleblower experts about the pressure inside your practice. We build the case with you around the clinical work, the instructions and the government claims, and find pain-practice fraud whistleblower lawyers who can pursue what your account exposes. You bring the knowledge of what happened inside; we bring the expertise and commitment to stay beside you throughout the case.

WHISTLEBLOWER JUSTICE NETWORK CAN HELP YOU
Make a difference.
Whistleblower Justice NetworkReport Fraud
100% CONFIDENTIALFREE CONSULTATION24 / 7 / 365