Contents
In the Maryland physician COVID-visit upcoding appeal, prosecutors alleged that a physician billed brief drive-through testing encounters as level-four office visits and backed the claims with records of care never provided. The Fourth Circuit reversed the acquittal and upheld a new trial on July 17, 2025. The criminal health care fraud case concerned the physician’s billing at Drs ERgent Care, also known as First Call Medical Center and Chesapeake ERgent Care.
For a clinician or coder who watched a brief encounter become a high-level claim, the case puts the billing instruction, the patient’s actual care and the chart beside one another. It shows how a coding fraud case turns on the gap between the visit and the claim.
According to the appellate opinion’s account of the criminal trial, the Maryland urgent-care business shifted toward COVID testing when the pandemic arrived. Patients could complete forms beforehand, drive into the parking lot for a nasal swab and temperature check, then pull under a tent for a brief video conversation with a provider. Insurers, including Medicare, paid for most visits.
The opinion quotes the physician’s instruction about the pace:
we want them in and out of the tent in under 5 minutes total.
Clinic physician’s instruction, quoted in the Fourth Circuit’s opinion, July 17, 2025
The five charged visits were all billed at level four: code 99204 for four new patients and 99214 for one established patient. The opinion says the clinic charged $354 for each new-patient visit and $231 for each established-patient visit, with nearly 1500 patients coming through on some days. Medicare was the payer for three counts and CareFirst for the other two.
The government also presented evidence that staff had been instructed to code COVID testing visits at level four, or level five for symptomatic patients. That puts the management instruction alongside the individual encounter in this physician upcoding dispute. An instruction applied across patients can explain how the same billing choice keeps appearing in the claims. We see the problem in that pairing: move patients through quickly, then bill them all at a high level. When the claim goes to Medicare, taxpayers have money at stake in the gap between the care and the code.
Office evaluation and management coding changed in 2021, making the work behind the code central to this case. Under the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services’ January 2021 explanation, office levels beginning January 1 could be selected through medical decision-making or the reporting practitioner’s qualifying total time on the service date. A medically appropriate history and examination remained relevant, but their length no longer selected the level.
The physician defended these claims through medical decision-making. As the appellate opinion explains, he argued that ordering and reviewing rapid and PCR tests satisfied the data requirement, and that the patients presented an undiagnosed new problem with an uncertain prognosis. The dispute centered on that second proposition. The CPT Manual’s definition required a possible condition likely to carry a high risk of substantial illness without treatment.
That is why the minutes in the tent did not answer the whole question. The court examined the problems addressed, the tests reviewed, the risk assessment and the treatment recommended. Those details connect the clinician’s work to the level the insurer was asked to pay.
The criminal case also turned on discrepancies between patients’ accounts and the records sent to their insurers. In the appellate court’s description of the testimony, one patient recalled a nasal swab and a short oral questionnaire, while her chart recorded temperature, pulse, oxygen saturation and respiration checks that she said never happened. Another patient denied receiving a results call, although her record described a lengthy conversation about the test and her overall health.
A provider likewise testified that she had not performed all the checks recorded in a patient’s chart. The chart said “the pharynx is without exudates.” The provider had done nothing that would tell her whether that finding was true. The opinion says some evidence pointed to templates that automatically populated physical-examination results. It treated the possibility of a clinic-wide template policy as evidence bearing on the physician’s knowledge and involvement.
We would want to know who made those entries appear and what the person treating the patient actually did. An automatically filled examination finding can travel from a template into a medical record and then into the insurer’s payment decision. Here, patient and provider testimony gave the jury a way to examine that journey.
Much of the evidence the appeals court found persuasive came from the defense. The physician described most COVID patients as presenting minimal or low risk and described basic treatment, including rest, hydration and over-the-counter medicine. His expert explained the coding framework and agreed that those treatments fit a lower level. The court said the jury could accept the expert’s explanation while rejecting his conclusion that these claims were correctly coded.
Staff concerns and a CareFirst audit also mattered. The auditor described the testing encounters as basic, lower-level evaluation and management, reporting an error rate of 100 percent for the clinic’s level-four codes. CareFirst had not obtained all the clinic’s records. The court considered that testimony alongside the clinical accounts and the disputed chart entries.
The government’s billing expert, meanwhile, had not specifically testified that these codes were improper and acknowledged unfamiliarity with the pandemic-era rules. The court explained that much of the crucial coding and treatment evidence arrived only when the defense presented its case. We find that a striking hole in a prosecution built around the choice of billing codes. The weaknesses in the government’s presentation helped explain why the new-trial order survived.
For a healthcare billing case like this, useful physician billing evidence connects the claim with the encounter and the decisions behind it. When we help someone report physician practice fraud, we examine the service date, payer, submitted code, clinical record, billing instructions and what employees or patients can explain firsthand. The medical decision-making documented for the visit, or qualifying practitioner time when time selected the level, gives the claim its clinical context.
The Journal of AHIMA’s 2017 article Busting Bad Medicine: a Call to Action Addressing Healthcare, Fraud, Waste, and Abuse makes the point directly:
Fraud examiners and investigators will not just stop at documentation alone. They will ask for trustworthy witnesses who can tell them what they know about the fraud.
That distinction has particular force when the chart itself is disputed. The clinician who performed the visit can explain the examination, the coder can explain the level, and the employee who received the billing instruction can explain how it reached the claim. In this criminal case, testimony about all of those pieces gave the court more to consider than the submitted code alone.
The same gap between a visit and its billed level has supported a civil whistleblower case. In the CityMD settlement announced in May 2018, the urgent-care practice agreed to pay $6,606,251 and admitted billing for longer or more complex services than it furnished or documented. That resolution also covered claims using credentialed physicians’ billing identifiers for work performed by uncredentialed physicians.
A whistleblower brought the CityMD case, and the government joined it. A whistleblower case under the False Claims Act can pay 15% to 30% of what the government recovers.
If you worked in a testing clinic and saw billing instructions override the care actually delivered, speak with our whistleblower experts. We know why a template, a coding directive and the person who treated the patient can tell different stories, and we bring in physician-billing whistleblower lawyers who can build the case with us. We stay beside you as that firsthand knowledge becomes the foundation of your case.