Contents
VNS Health agreed to pay $954,416 in its Far Rockaway ACT Medicaid settlement over claims that it billed for services it failed to provide or document. The settlement resolved claims concerning 103 patients from January 1, 2014 through December 31, 2018.
A program assistant brought the qui tam case, and the United States joined it. The U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of New York announced the settlement on June 26, 2024. This Medicaid provider fraud case concerned the ACT program that Visiting Nurse Service of New York, doing business as VNS Health, operated in Far Rockaway, Queens.
Assertive Community Treatment provides health care for people with serious mental illness. VNS was licensed by the New York State Office of Mental Health to provide it, and Medicaid paid the provider monthly for each enrolled patient. Those payments depended on compliance with the program’s regulations, guidelines and contractual requirements.
The required work reached from a patient’s first assessment to ongoing treatment. Intake forms and initial assessments supplied background information and a baseline for care. Immediate-needs assessments addressed safety, food, clothing, shelter and medical needs. Comprehensive assessments tracked changing needs, while service plans set objectives and the services intended to help patients reach their recovery goals.
Psychiatric visits and progress notes belonged to that same course of care. The notes recorded contacts and attempted contacts, progress toward goals and significant events.
VNS admitted receiving full monthly payments when its progress notes supported only partial payment. We see the absurdity in asking Medicaid to pay more than the provider’s own notes justify. Full payment. Partial support.
The United States’ complaint in intervention connected particular patients’ missing services or records to the months Medicaid paid for. Its examples show how an assessment date, a plan approval or a psychiatric-visit record can explain a payment that otherwise looks routine.
The government alleged that one patient’s service plan sat between development and completed review while Medicaid payments continued. An employee who knows the approval process can explain where the plan stood during the months the provider was paid. The complaint put the sequence and the money together:
For example, for one patient who entered the program on or about July 23, 2014 (“Patient 4”), there is a seven-month delay between the date that the service plan was developed (January 2017) and the date the plan was recorded, reviewed, and approved (August 2017). Nevertheless, VNS improperly received over $12,800 in capitation payments from Medicaid for this patient for that time period.
For another patient, the government alleged that VNS failed to provide or record monthly psychiatric visits in October 2013 and additional months during 2014, 2015 and 2016. The complaint said VNS improperly received more than $13,600 for those months. This example reaches beyond the settlement’s stated period: the October 2013 payment predates its January 1, 2014 start.
The allegation tied the payment to the missing visit or its record. A program employee’s knowledge of contacts and documentation can help explain which part of that account failed.
The government also alleged that VNS failed to conduct or document an immediate-needs assessment for a patient who entered the program in May 2014, yet received $1,591 for that month. That assessment concerned such basic needs as food, shelter and medical care.
For someone who handles intake, this example brings the admission to the program, the assessment and the payment together. The required work concerned a patient’s immediate needs, and the government alleged that Medicaid paid even though VNS had failed to conduct or document it.
VNS accepted responsibility for failures to complete required work, finish it on time and obtain supervisory review. Its admissions show where the healthcare workflow broke down.
For intake forms and initial assessments, VNS admitted failures to complete them, finish them on time or obtain necessary supervisory review and approval. It acknowledged the same kinds of failures for immediate-needs assessments and comprehensive assessments.
VNS also admitted failing to complete service plans, complete them on time or obtain the necessary review and approval. For psychiatric visits, its stated admission was failure to document visits. VNS also admitted recording progress notes several days or even weeks after the patient contact.
A missing assessment, an unapproved plan and a note entered weeks after a contact describe different points in the work. We want to understand which one you saw, who handled it and how the monthly payment followed.
The United States treated the monthly requests for capitation as claims under the False Claims Act. It alleged that VNS knowingly submitted or caused false claims for those payments. The U.S. Attorney’s Office’s Civil Frauds Unit handled the case, with assistance from the Department of Health and Human Services’ Office of Inspector General and the New York Medicaid Fraud Control Unit.
VNS Choice’s earlier capitation cases concerned enrollment in a managed long-term care plan. Its delayed-disenrollment settlement addressed retention of payments after services or eligibility ended.
A managed care plan receives a fixed periodic payment for each enrolled member. In Far Rockaway, the issue was the ACT provider’s required services, documentation and monthly payment level. The same word, capitation, appears in both stories, but the records explaining the payment are different.
For an ACT service-payment case, we work with you to connect patient contacts, required assessments, service-plan approvals and progress notes to the monthly claims. The Far Rockaway examples show why both the content of the record and its timing belong in that comparison.
The Journal of AHIMA’s October 2017 article Busting Bad Medicine: a Call to Action Addressing Healthcare, Fraud, Waste, and Abuse describes checking treatment dates, treatment types and clinician signatures against the health record. It then makes the point that gives an insider’s knowledge its value:
Fraud examiners and investigators will not just stop at documentation alone. They will ask for trustworthy witnesses who can tell them what they know about the fraud.
A note can show when someone entered it. A person familiar with the work can explain what happened before that entry, how the review process operated and why the file looked the way it did. That is where operational knowledge has a place beside clinical and payment records.
We work with the insider to connect those parts: the month being paid for, the service level the records support and the decisions inside the provider. Your account of the workflow can give the dates and entries meaning. That is the conversation worth having if the payment records and the care you know tell different stories.
A whistleblower case under the False Claims Act can pay 15% to 30% of what the government recovers. In the VNS Health case, the federal whistleblower-share order specified a whistleblower’s share of 17% of the federal settlement payment. We work through Medicaid whistleblower rewards with you as part of building your case.
If you work with ACT contacts, assessments or billing and know why the monthly payment exceeds the care or documentation behind it, speak to one of our whistleblower experts. We build your strongest Medicaid whistleblower case around your knowledge, bring in Medicaid fraud whistleblower lawyers who understand behavioral health service payments, and stay beside you throughout the case.