City of New York: Monthly Bills Without the Required Sessions

Whistleblower Justice Network

In the New York City Medicaid settlement over school counseling claims, the City agreed to pay $1,375,000 to resolve allegations that its Department of Education billed for monthly services without delivering the required sessions. The government alleged that the department’s own service records showed fewer sessions than the payment rule required. For someone who knows the counseling records or the billing, that is the heart of the case.

The U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Eastern District of New York announced the settlement on January 13, 2014. A whistleblower initiated the False Claims Act case, and the government took up the case with its own complaint alleging false claims for psychological counseling for special-education students in city public schools. The allegations concerned billing between 2001 and 2004. This counseling case was separate from the 2009 statewide school Medicaid settlement involving New York State and New York City.

How the Monthly Counseling Bundle Worked

The monthly counseling bundle required at least two psychological counseling sessions for the same student within a calendar month. Under the historical payment rule described in the government’s announcement, Medicaid paid the Department of Education a flat $223 for a qualifying month. Half came from the federal government. Fewer than the required sessions meant no payment for that student for that month. A student could receive some counseling and still fall short of the minimum for the bundle.

That is what makes this form of Medicaid provider billing distinctive. The government alleged that the department knowingly sought the monthly payment despite delivering too few sessions. The alleged false claim concerned the entire month’s entitlement to payment.

The Records Behind the Government’s Allegations

The government’s example involved 15 months of requested payments for one student during the 2001 to 2002 and 2002 to 2003 school years. The government alleged that the Department of Education’s own service records showed fewer than the required sessions in 12 of those months.

In that account, the school system held the records that contradicted its requests for payment. That matters to an insider because the useful knowledge can be very specific: which student received counseling, when the sessions occurred and which month appeared on the claim. A service record becomes especially revealing when it can be connected to the payment requested for the same student and month.

We find it absurd that, in the government’s account, the department’s own files supplied the reason to reject its bills. The alleged mismatch was already recorded inside the institution asking for the money.

What Claims Processing Can Miss

A study of health care fraud controls published in the Journal of Insurance Medicine in 1996 explained a weakness in the claims-processing systems it examined. Their checks could assess who and what qualified for payment while accepting the account of treatment presented in the bill. The paper, Health Care Fraud Control Understanding The Challenge, put the assumption plainly:

Clearly such systems do not do anything to verify that the service was in fact provided as claimed, or that the diagnosis is genuine, or that the patient knows anything at all about the alleged treatment.

Health Care Fraud Control Understanding The Challenge, Journal of Insurance Medicine, 1996

The distinction helps explain the counseling case. The underlying service record supplied the separate account of care against which the government tested that request. Knowing how to read the school’s record can therefore matter as much as knowing how to read its bill.

A Public School System Faced the False Claims Act Case

The City of New York was the settling defendant, and the government’s allegations concerned its Department of Education’s billing. The U.S. Attorney’s Office handled the case with assistance from a special agent of the Department of Health and Human Services’ Office of Inspector General. In announcing the settlement, the U.S. Attorney expressly included local governmental agencies among the entities the office would pursue for seeking federal reimbursement they were not entitled to receive.

The government’s criticism also reached beyond the bill. It identified harm to students needing psychological support as well as to public funds. We share that concern: in the alleged conduct, the missing sessions were both the reason the monthly claim failed and care the students had not received.

Can You Get Paid for Reporting Medicaid Fraud?

A whistleblower case under the False Claims Act can pay 15% to 30% of what the government recovers. In this case, the settlement allocated a 15% whistleblower reward to the person who initiated it.

That share came out of the settlement amount payable to the United States. The City also agreed to pay $40,000 in False Claims Act attorney fees, separately.

A whistleblower started this case, and the government took it up. For a school employee who understands a mismatch between the services recorded and the money claimed, it is a concrete example of where that knowledge can lead.

How We Examine School Counseling Claims With You

We work with you to connect the student’s service record to the month’s claim and the payment rule that governed it. In the counseling allegations, that meant whether the recorded sessions reached the minimum for the bundle. Your knowledge of how the record reached the billing staff, and what they understood it to show, can help explain the decisions behind the claim.

The claiming method determines the comparison. School administrative claiming can use time studies to identify Medicaid activities and allocate staff costs. We start with the kind of payment at issue, then examine the service or activity records that were supposed to support it.

For a counseling provider, the useful perspective may be the sessions actually delivered. For a billing employee, it may be the treatment of a month that fell below the threshold. We bring those accounts together to understand what was claimed, what the school knew and where the two diverged.

You Know the Sessions Behind the Bill

If you know how a school billed for counseling that its service records could not support, your account belongs at the center of the case. We build the case with you, bring in Medicaid fraud whistleblower lawyers who understand school billing and public-agency claims, and stay beside you as the case develops. Talk with our whistleblower experts about the school counseling claims you saw.

WHISTLEBLOWER JUSTICE NETWORK CAN HELP YOU
Make a difference.
Whistleblower Justice NetworkReport Fraud
100% CONFIDENTIALFREE CONSULTATION24 / 7 / 365