Jier Shin Korea: The Fuel Contract Won by Mistake

Whistleblower Justice Network

In the Jier Shin Korea antitrust settlement, the company and its president agreed to pay $2 million to resolve allegations that they helped rig bids for fuel supplied to U.S. military bases in South Korea.

Jier Shin Korea was a small, privately held logistics company in Seoul. It partnered with Hyundai Oilbank to supply the military, with Jier Shin acting as the prime contractor. The government’s civil complaint alleged that the company’s president directly participated in its conduct. The Department of Justice announced the civil resolution on April 8, 2020.

How the Military Fuel Bids Were Divided

The alleged bid rigging followed the way the military bought fuel. Some contracts awarded business one delivery location at a time. Another awarded all listed locations together. The complaint describes agreements tailored to both.

The Defense Logistics Agency bought fuel for military vehicles and heating buildings through its Post, Camps, and Stations contracts. Each delivery location had a separate line item, and bidders could choose which lines to bid on. The lowest price won each line. That gave suppliers a way to divide a solicitation among themselves while still submitting bids that looked separate.

The Army and Air Force Exchange Service bought gasoline for military personnel and their families to use in personal vehicles. Its 2008 fuel contract went to the lowest bidder across all listed locations. Keeping rivals out of that bidding protected an entire contract, rather than a single delivery point.

Those purchasing arrangements explain Jier Shin’s role. The company supplied logistics and held the government contract. Its refinery partner supplied the fuel. In the complaint’s account, coordination could reach both the offer sent to the military and the choice of supplier behind it.

Bids Designed to Lose

For the 2006 base fuel contracts, the government alleged that Jier Shin Korea, Hyundai Oilbank, GS Caltex and SK Energy divided delivery locations through meetings, phone calls and emails. On a line reserved for someone else, the others agreed either to stay out or to bid high enough to lose. The complaint alleged that the resulting awards followed the agreed allocations.

The same discussions allegedly included a promise not to compete with SK Energy for the exchange-service contract. When that bidding came around, GS Caltex submitted a significantly higher offer. Hyundai Oilbank and Jier Shin declined to bid even after the buyer explicitly requested their participation.

The buyer asked for more competition. According to the complaint, the companies had already agreed to withhold it.

When Winning Was a Mistake

The 2009 round allegedly repeated the allocation arrangement, with Hanjin and S-Oil joining the bidding group. Hanjin provided transportation and logistics, while S-Oil provided fuel. The government said the original participants agreed to give them some delivery locations previously allocated to others.

Jier Shin Korea allegedly kept the contract it won with Hyundai Oilbank while substituting GS Caltex as fuel supplier to restore the agreed allocation, as the companion Hyundai case explains.

A Lower Bid Could Still Overcharge the Military

For the 2013 base fuel contracts, the complaint alleged that Jier Shin and the other participants again communicated about allocations and prices. Jier Shin’s complaint describes Hanjin and S-Oil taking the 2013 awards with bids below the cartel’s prices but above competitive levels; see S-Oil’s case.

Hanjin and S-Oil won nearly all the line items, while Jier Shin and other participants won a few small ones.

The complaint alleged that the wider conspiracy overcharged American taxpayers by well over $100 million.

Jier Shin Korea Joint Settlement Installments: A Shared Bill

Jier Shin Korea and its president shared responsibility for the full civil settlement obligation. Under the proposed judgment and attached False Claims Act agreement, money paid under the False Claims Act counted toward the antitrust bill.

The proposed judgment set out an initial $1 million installment followed by two installments of $500,000 each.

S-Oil’s civil settlement in the same fuel investigation used the same payment-credit approach. Its False Claims Act payment reduced its civil antitrust obligation.

How Much of a Settlement Does a Whistleblower Get?

A whistleblower case under the False Claims Act can pay 15% to 30% of what the government recovers.

The Department of Justice described Jier Shin’s resolution as the sixth False Claims Act settlement arising from the military-fuel conspiracy. It alleged that Jier Shin and its president made false statements to the government about their agreement not to compete.

The complaint also described the payment chain: after winning contracts, participants submitted invoices to Defense Department offices in Columbus, Ohio, and received government payments. For an insider, that connects the private agreement among bidders to the public money it brought in.

How Is Bid Rigging Detected?

Bid rigging can come to light through an insider who connects bidding decisions with competitors’ communications and the work awarded afterward. In Jier Shin’s case, the government said its civil investigation began with a whistleblower’s qui tam case. The whistleblower was a South Korean citizen and resident. The government’s complaint then connected particular procurement rounds to agreed allocations, deliberately losing bids and a supplier change after an unintended win.

Someone who knows the delivery locations and supplier relationships may explain why a bid or supply arrangement made sense to the participating companies while costing the buyer more.

You Know Why the Supplier Changed

Bring our whistleblower experts the contract award and the instruction that changed Jier Shin Korea’s fuel supplier afterward.

WHISTLEBLOWER JUSTICE NETWORK CAN HELP YOU
Make a difference.
Whistleblower Justice NetworkReport Fraud
100% CONFIDENTIALFREE CONSULTATION24 / 7 / 365