Florida Mesh-Removal Surgeon: Buying Referrals for Settlement-Driven Surgery

Whistleblower Justice Network

In a mesh removal plea announced on September 17, 2021, a Florida urogynecologist admitted participating in a scheme that paid bribes and kickbacks for patients seeking transvaginal-mesh removal surgery. The scheme turned women pursuing compensation for alleged implant injuries into paid referrals. For someone inside a surgical practice or patient-financing business, the revealing connection is between who sent the patient, who paid for that referral and what the operation meant for her settlement.

In his guilty plea, the surgeon admitted participating in the paid-referral scheme. The Justice Department’s account describes him and others paying a patient recruiter to send women for removal surgery. Some patients traveled across the United States to undergo the procedures. The business opportunity depended on an operation that could increase a woman’s recovery from mesh litigation.

The Surgeon Paid the Recruiter

The surgeon bought referrals from an owner of Surgical Assistance Inc. The owner of Surgical Assistance had also pleaded guilty to participating in the same scheme.

According to the Justice Department’s account of court filings and facts presented at the plea proceeding, the payments were bribes and kickbacks exchanged for referrals.

A person working with the surgeon’s payments may see money leaving the practice. Someone handling patient referrals may see the corresponding arrivals. Our work is to connect those accounts: what the money bought, which patients it concerned and who arranged the exchange.

Removal Meant a Larger Settlement

The criminal scheme exploited a difference in what women could receive from transvaginal-mesh litigation. The Justice Department described the incentive in its account of the plea proceeding, using TVM for transvaginal mesh:

The scheme sought to take advantage of the fact that female patients who had their TVM implants surgically removed were entitled to receive larger settlements than female patients whose inserts remained implanted.

Justice Department, account of the mesh-removal plea proceeding, September 17, 2021

The prospect of a larger settlement made a second operation a business opportunity. Women seeking compensation for implant injuries became patients a surgeon would pay to obtain.

The women had already brought lawsuits over alleged injuries from their implants. According to the plea announcement, the surgeon and recruiter sought to profit from those cases. The patient’s effort to obtain compensation became the setting for another business transaction, with the surgeon paying the person who brought her to him.

For an employee who heard how removal was presented to patients, that is a concrete distinction. The clinical discussion, the settlement discussion and the referral payment concern the same decision, but they come from different people with different financial interests. We work with insiders to understand who made each representation and how it related to the surgery and the payment.

The Surgery Created a Debt Worth Buying

The broader criminal prosecution also alleged that women’s medical debts were purchased and resold for profit, a debt trade covered in the mesh-removal financier’s case.

Connecting Referral Payments to a Whistleblower Case

For a civil whistleblower case involving government healthcare payments, we examine the connection between the paid referral, the treatment and the bill sent to the government. That inquiry follows the money through the particular business you know.

A 2020 Journal of Forensic and Investigative Accounting paper on federal healthcare fraud laws explains that the federal kickback prohibition reaches both paying and receiving compensation tied to services paid for by federal health care programs. Its discussion shows why the payer and recipient both matter when examining a referral arrangement. It also describes the False Claims Act as a route for civil whistleblower cases involving those payments.

For an insider describing a separate government-billing scheme, we also need to understand the claims: who billed, for which treatment and how the paid referral affected that business. Referral knowledge and billing knowledge can sit with different people. Our whistleblower experts work with you to connect them and assess the case your information supports.

A separate whistleblower case under the False Claims Act can pay 15% to 30% of what the government recovers.

Who Paid for the Patient?

If your work exposed payments for mesh-removal referrals, patient-debt transactions or the bills connected to them, tell our whistleblower experts how the arrangement worked. We work with you to build your strongest case, bring in healthcare whistleblower lawyers with experience in referral-payment and billing schemes, and remain your partners throughout the process.

WHISTLEBLOWER JUSTICE NETWORK CAN HELP YOU
Make a difference.
Whistleblower Justice NetworkReport Fraud
100% CONFIDENTIALFREE CONSULTATION24 / 7 / 365