Apex Medical Technologies: Four Times the Investment in the First Month

Whistleblower Justice Network

In the Apex Medical Technologies Reliance settlement, Reliance, its owners and two physician-owned distributorships agreed to pay $1 million over alleged kickbacks for spinal implant use. The Apex allegations followed a circle of money: a surgeon selected the implants, the hospital bought them, and the distributor shared the resulting profits with the surgeon. The physician choosing the product had a financial interest in the sale.

The government described Apex Medical Technologies, LLC as a Reliance spinal implant distributor operating in Southern California. According to the Justice Department, Reliance Medical Systems, founded in 2006, built a network of more than a dozen physician-owned distributorships, including Apex and Kronos Spinal Technologies. Apex’s part of the story turns on an investment, a change in implant use and the payments that followed.

How the Apex Arrangement Worked

Apex allegedly paid a physician-owner from profits generated by the implants he used in his own surgeries. The government’s amended complaint traces the arrangement from the surgeon’s entry into the business to the hospital’s purchases.

The complaint alleges that in May 2010, the surgeon paid $5,000 for a 20% ownership stake. Apex paid him $20,117 that same month. Before agreeing to invest in April, he had never used Reliance implants. Between April and December, he used them in more than 90% of his spinal fusion surgeries.

The complaint traces the revenue to Community Memorial Hospital in Ventura, California, alleging that it paid Apex $1,421,484 during that period for Reliance implants used in the surgeon’s operations. Apex allegedly shared the profits from those sales with him. The complaint’s payment table lists $438,570 paid to the surgeon from May 2010 through June 2012.

Implantable medical devices are often physician preference items: the surgeon can strongly influence both the brand and the type, while the hospital makes the purchase. The Department of Health and Human Services’ Office of Inspector General describes that split in its March 2013 alert on physician-owned entities. A physician-owned distributorship puts the physician on the selling side of the transaction as well.

For an implant salesperson, the alleged change is recognizable. A surgeon who had never used a product became an almost exclusive user around the time he agreed to invest in its distributor. The investment records, utilization records and payments tell that story together. The government’s allegation was that the financial return helped drive the clinical choice.

How Does Reimbursement Work for Medical Devices?

For implanted medical devices, Medicare generally pays the hospital for the procedure with the medical device cost included, while the hospital buys the implant. In Apex’s case, the government followed the implant sale into the surgeon’s professional claims and the hospital’s claims for the associated care.

The complaint alleges that Medicare paid both the surgeon’s professional claims and Community Memorial’s hospital claims while he had a financial interest in Apex. It puts the hospital’s payments for services connected with his fusion surgeries using Reliance implants at approximately $960,636.

These payments explain how the distributor entered a False Claims Act case. The government alleged that Reliance and Apex paid the physician-investors to order and use the implants, causing those physicians and their hospitals to submit Medicare claims tainted by kickbacks. The distributor’s revenue came through hospital purchasing. The government’s money reached the transaction through the bills for surgery and hospital care.

That connection matters to someone who knows the sales side of the business. A hospital invoice identifies the implant purchase. The surgeon’s use of that implant connects the invoice to a patient procedure, and the procedure connects it to the Medicare claims. The complaint followed that chain down to individual patients.

More Surgery Meant More Implants

The government also alleged that the financial incentives led the Apex physician-owner to perform unnecessary or excessive surgery. One patient example shows what that meant beyond a change of implant brand.

For Patient A, the amended complaint alleges that the surgeon performed a seven-level laminectomy and fusion when only a two-level operation without fusion was indicated. He ordered Reliance implants for the operation. Medicare paid both his professional claim and the hospital’s claim, and Community Memorial paid Apex $20,744 for the implants.

According to the complaint, the patient suffered excessive blood loss and severe postoperative pain. Another operation was needed to remove all the Reliance hardware. The alleged incentive reached the extent of the operation itself: more implanted hardware meant more products sold through the business in which the surgeon held an interest.

The complaint also describes a hospital review of the surgeon’s instrumented fusion surgeries, followed by his suspension and departure from Community Memorial. It alleges that Apex’s nonphysician owners learned of reports that patients had suffered severe complications from unnecessarily invasive surgeries and took no action in response.

Two physicians separately brought a whistleblower case over medical necessity. As the Justice Department explained in its announcement, the government joined their medical-necessity claims and brought its own kickback lawsuit against the surgeon and the Reliance defendants. The Apex settlement belongs to that government kickback case.

The Physician Owner Missing From the Vendor Forms

Reliance allegedly concealed the surgeon’s ownership interest in vendor forms submitted to Michigan hospitals. The complaint says he obtained privileges at hospitals in the Detroit area after leaving Community Memorial. The government’s amended complaint describes forms submitted in November 2011 and May 2012 certifying that:

The complaint alleges that the defendants knew those forms were false because the surgeon remained an Apex investor until August 10, 2012.

According to the complaint, the physician held an ownership interest inside the distributor. On the hospital’s vendor form, no physician owned any part of it. For someone in purchasing or vendor management, that form is where the financial relationship behind an implant order could disappear from the hospital’s view.

What the Reliance Settlement Resolved

The Justice Department announced the joint civil settlement on July 1, 2022. It covered Reliance, its settling owners and the two physician-owned distributorships named in the lawsuit, Apex and Kronos.

The government’s account described a broader business model in which distributors paid physicians according to referrals, made false statements to health care providers and removed physicians who did not generate enough business.

The same announcement reported more than $9.25 million previously recovered from owners of Reliance distributorships in earlier settlements.

What Are Some Examples of Kickbacks in Healthcare?

Alleged kickbacks in healthcare can take the form of distributor profits linked to a surgeon’s implant choices, as in Apex, or commissions benefiting someone close to the surgeon.

The government’s complaint against DS Medical alleged that each time a surgeon ordered implants through the distributor, his fiancée received a commission.

The 2020 Journal of Forensic and Investigative Accounting paper A Forensic Accountant’s Guide to the Most Potent Federal Laws Used Against Healthcare Fraud explains that anti-kickback rules reach indirect compensation as well as payments made directly to the person directing covered business. That distinction helps explain why the payment recipient matters alongside the surgeon’s product choice. Apex’s alleged return went to the surgeon as an owner.

What Evidence Is Needed to Prove Fraud?

For an arrangement like the one alleged at Apex, the evidence must connect the financial incentive to implant choices and the resulting Medicare claims. We build that connection with the insider who knows how the business worked.

The government alleged that Reliance generated daily surgery reports showing the number and types of operations using its implants, which its owners reviewed. Those reports could show what the people running the distributor knew about the business its physician-investors generated. A medical device insider may know that side of the story. A hospital insider may know what the vendor disclosed and what happened to patients. Our work brings those parts together into a medical device whistleblower case.

A whistleblower case under the False Claims Act can pay 15% to 30% of what the government recovers.

You Know What Drove the Implant Orders

If you saw distributor payments follow a surgeon’s implant orders or ownership disappear from a hospital disclosure, speak with our Whistleblower Experts about who profited from those implant orders. We build your strongest medical device whistleblower case with you and bring in medical device kickback whistleblower lawyers who understand physician-owned distributorships, hospital purchasing and Medicare claims. We stay beside you as your partners throughout the case.

WHISTLEBLOWER JUSTICE NETWORK CAN HELP YOU
Make a difference.
Whistleblower Justice NetworkReport Fraud
100% CONFIDENTIALFREE CONSULTATION24 / 7 / 365