University of Phoenix: Recruiter Compensation and Student Aid Claims

Whistleblower Justice Network

In the University of Phoenix False Claims Act case, the university agreed to a $67.5 million civil settlement over allegations that it tied recruiters’ pay to enrollment in violation of federal student-aid conditions. Two former employees brought the case. The Justice Department announced the settlement on December 15, 2009.

The allegation connected an admissions-office pay decision to the university’s access to government money. We see the wrong at the center of that allegation: taxpayers funding student aid on one set of terms while the school allegedly paid recruiters on another.

Recruiter Pay and Federal Student Aid

The Phoenix whistleblowers alleged that enrollment results drove recruiter compensation in violation of the conditions for participating in federal student aid. For an admissions employee, the practical question is familiar: what actually determines a recruiter’s pay?

A written pay policy and the way managers applied it are both part of that inquiry. We would want to understand how enrollment results affected compensation, what managers told recruiters, and how those practices compared with the school’s commitments to the government. Someone who worked with those decisions can explain the connection between the enrollment count and the paycheck. In the Education Management Corp. settlement announced in November 2015, the government likewise alleged that recruiter compensation depended on enrollment despite certifications of compliance.

The Promise Behind Student-Aid Payments

A false promise used to obtain access to a government-funded program can affect the claims that follow. That is why compliance certifications and participation agreements matter in education-funding cases. The evidence can reach back to the promise that opened the door to the money. In the Weston Educational case, the Eighth Circuit’s October 2016 decision said an allegedly false promise to maintain accurate student records could have mattered to the government’s decision to admit the school to the aid program.

The point for an education insider is concrete. A school’s assurance about how it will operate can matter before an individual student’s payment is processed. Records showing what the school promised, how it actually operated and what its decision-makers knew can connect the admissions office to the federal funding at issue.

Phoenix’s case concerned recruiter compensation. The promise opens the door to the money. A pay policy sitting in an admissions manager’s files can help explain why that bargain was allegedly broken.

Can I Proceed After Declination?

University of Phoenix’s whistleblowers did. The government declined to take over their case, but backed them in court, and the university agreed to settle. The federal court’s December 2009 order confirms the government’s decision to decline.

We help you address the government’s decision about taking over and what continuing after declination means for your case. Our conversation starts with your evidence and the people who understand it, and we stay with you as the case develops.

What the University of Phoenix Settlement Paid

The University of Phoenix settlement paid the two whistleblowers $19 million collectively from the $67.5 million civil settlement. That award puts the recovery in perspective: former employees who understood the practice shared in the result.

A whistleblower case under the False Claims Act can pay 15% to 30% of what the government recovers. The Congressional Research Service’s 2009 report, Qui Tam: The False Claims Act and Related Federal Statutes, explains the incentive: people who bring cases in the government’s name receive a share of the recovered money.

The Records Behind the Recruiting Numbers

For a case about enrollment-based pay and student aid, we examine evidence connecting the compensation practice to government funding. That connection involves the promised conditions of participation, the incentive employees worked under and the records used to administer it.

Our work with an insider starts by understanding what their role allowed them to see. Someone familiar with recruiting may explain how managers used enrollment counts. Someone familiar with payroll may explain how compensation changed. Someone familiar with compliance may connect those practices to the assurances the school gave. We work with you to bring those views together and understand what the decision-makers knew.

You can start that conversation with the part you understand. A compensation formula, a management instruction or a participation promise may be where your knowledge begins. We work with you to build the case connecting what happened inside the school to the government’s money.

You Know How the Recruiting Numbers Became Pay

If you saw enrollment targets drive compensation while a school promised compliance to obtain student aid, speak to one of our Whistleblower Experts about how recruiting pay worked. We connect your knowledge of the pay system to the funding at stake, bring in education-fraud whistleblower lawyers and stay beside you to build your strongest education fraud whistleblower case.

WHISTLEBLOWER JUSTICE NETWORK CAN HELP YOU
Make a difference.
Whistleblower Justice NetworkReport Fraud
100% CONFIDENTIALFREE CONSULTATION24 / 7 / 365