Contents
A whistleblower brings a qui tam case under the False Claims Act under seal, keeping the complaint out of public view while the government investigates. The government receives both the allegations and the evidence behind them before the court permits formal delivery of the complaint to the company. For an insider who knows how the business sent a false bill, changed a payment record or shifted its own costs onto taxpayers, this puts that evidence before the government first.
The government receives a complaint setting out the allegations and a separate written disclosure of substantially all material evidence and information the whistleblower possesses. The False Claims Act requires both.
The complaint puts the alleged scheme into a case: what the company did and how it involved government money. The disclosure statement supplies the evidence behind that account.
A historical government overview from the Eastern District of Pennsylvania describes that separation plainly. The complaint goes to the court. The disclosure statement goes to the Justice Department rather than being filed in court alongside it.
That evidence can start well before an invoice. In healthcare, it may concern diagnosis additions and deletions that feed a Medicare Advantage payment. In procurement, it may concern the pricing information behind a government contract. In grant-funded research, it may concern the experimental evidence used to support an application or progress report. The employee who knows how that information was created can explain a connection that the final payment record leaves out. We work through those connections with you: the underlying information, the decision to use it and the government money it affected.
The complaint must remain under seal for at least 60 days, and the government can ask the court for extensions by showing the court a good reason. The government’s initial period for deciding whether to take over runs from its receipt of both the complaint and the material evidence and information.
The Justice Department investigates the allegations and considers whether to take primary responsibility for pursuing them. That review can involve the federal agency whose money is at issue as well as other investigators.
The Eastern District of Pennsylvania overview describes document and electronic-record demands, witness interviews, testimony and consultation with experts. The point for an insider is concrete: investigators examine the evidence behind the allegation, including what people know and what the business’s records show.
The Congressional Research Service’s 2009 report, Qui Tam: The False Claims Act and Related Federal Statutes, describes civil investigative demands as a way for the government to require evidence and testimony during its investigation. Those powers let investigators pursue material beyond the information provided at the outset.
In health care, procurement or grant-funded research, an investigator needs to understand what a record meant inside the business. A diagnosis change, a pricing disclosure or an experimental result has a place in that work. Your account can connect the record to the decision to use it in a claim for government money.
The case can go on if the government decides not to join, and we work through that decision with you and your False Claims Act whistleblower lawyers. If the government joins, it takes primary responsibility and the whistleblower remains part of the case. The government can also join particular claims within a case. A whistleblower case under the False Claims Act can pay 15% to 30% of what the government recovers.
The defendant receives formal service of the complaint only when the court orders it. Unsealing concerns access to the court filing. The Eastern District of Pennsylvania overview describes the government asking the court to unseal the whistleblower’s complaint and its notice that it is joining the case. In that account, other government filings remain sealed. We bring in whistleblower lawyers who know sealed False Claims Act cases in your industry.
The Supreme Court’s 2016 State Farm decision held that violating the seal does not automatically require dismissal. The underlying allegations make the government’s interest easy to understand. State Farm sold its own homeowners insurance and federal government-backed flood insurance. For customers affected by Hurricane Katrina who held both policies, State Farm was responsible for wind damage and the government paid for flood damage. The classification of the damage determined whose money paid the claim.
Former claims adjusters working for a State Farm contractor alleged that the insurer instructed adjusters to classify wind damage as flood damage. They had visited damaged homes to assess insurance payouts. Their allegation connected the work at those homes to the insurer’s financial incentive. Call it flood. Taxpayers pay.
State Farm argued that a break in the seal should end the case. The Supreme Court said no.
The Court explained that the seal principally protects the government’s investigation. Automatically ending a whistleblower’s case over a seal violation could deprive the government of the private help the law was designed to encourage. We see the absurdity: an insurer accused of shifting its own hurricane bills to taxpayers wanted a rule protecting the government’s investigation to shut that case down.
Filing under seal temporarily keeps the complaint out of public view, but does not itself provide permanent anonymity. We address anonymity and confidentiality with you and the False Claims Act whistleblower lawyers suited to your case. Those questions deserve attention to your circumstances, alongside the allegations and evidence you bring.
If what you know comes from your work inside the business, tell us what concerns you about coming forward. We make those concerns part of our work with you from the start, together with the facts connecting the conduct to government money.
If you hold records showing how a company put false information into a government payment, speak to one of our Whistleblower Experts about building your strongest False Claims Act case. We connect your knowledge of the business to the case and bring in False Claims Act whistleblower lawyers with experience in the program involved. We stay beside you from that first account through the case.