Contents
The HCA False Claims Act resolutions included a $745 million civil agreement in 2000 over alleged upcoding and improper billing, followed by a $631 million civil agreement in 2003 over alleged cost-report fraud and kickbacks. The allegations reached from a patient’s diagnosis code to the hospital’s annual reimbursement paperwork. If you worked in coding, reimbursement, home health or physician contracting, the familiar detail may be the expense someone renamed or the payment someone wanted treated as something else.
HCA, formerly known as Columbia/HCA, operated hospitals and home health businesses. The Justice Department’s December 14, 2000 announcement and June 26, 2003 announcement describe different civil resolutions. The later settlement reached hospital cost reports and physician kickbacks that the earlier civil package had left unresolved.
The first civil settlement covered five groups of billing allegations. They concerned what HCA said patients needed, how it coded their conditions, which business expenses it claimed and whether billed home health visits qualified for payment or happened at all. Medicare and Medicaid were central, but the allegations also reached TRICARE, the military’s health care program, and the Federal Employees’ Health Benefits Program.
HCA agreed to pay more than $95 million over outpatient laboratory billing allegations. The government alleged that the company billed for tests that were not medically necessary or had not been ordered by physicians, along with other billing violations. An insider who knows the physician’s order, the patient’s medical need and the bill can explain the gap between them.
More than $403 million addressed alleged upcoding. The government said HCA assigned false diagnosis codes to patient records to increase hospital reimbursement. The code was the connection between the description of the patient’s condition and the amount billed to the health program. In the criminal plea agreement announced the same day, Columbia Management Companies agreed to plead guilty to a charge involving upcoding Medicare bills for certain pneumonia patients.
The practical question for a coding insider is what supported the diagnosis that reached the bill, and who directed its use. The patient record and the billing decision belong in the same account.
HCA agreed to pay $50 million over allegations that it charged Medicare for marketing and advertising disguised as community education. Medicare reimbursed public-health education for the community, but did not reimburse advertising and marketing of a hospital’s services.
That distinction explains the alleged maneuver. The government said a hospital’s sales expense reached Medicare under a public-health description. We see a hospital promotion with the bill sent to taxpayers. Some public service. The campaign’s actual purpose matters more than the label on the expense.
Another $90 million resolved allegations that HCA charged Medicare for nonreimbursable costs of buying home health agencies, including agencies owned by Olsten Corporation and others in Florida, Georgia and Alabama. The government alleged that HCA concealed those purchase costs inside reimbursable management fees paid to third parties.
According to the government’s account, HCA used the management-fee description to get its purchase costs paid. For an employee who knew what a management payment actually purchased, the transaction’s history would explain something the fee description alone concealed.
The criminal plea agreement also called for Columbia Homecare Group to plead guilty over the purchase and operation of home health agencies, including kickbacks and fraudulent Medicare billing for management and personnel costs. Olsten had already paid nearly $41 million in a civil settlement arising from its alleged collusion with HCA in that conduct. That related resolution shows why the business on the other end of a payment can matter: the same arrangement can be visible from both the hospital buyer and the agency seller.
The remaining $106 million addressed allegations that HCA billed Medicare, Medicaid and TRICARE for home health visits involving patients who did not qualify, visits that were never performed and other billing violations. Here the disputed fact could be the patient’s eligibility or the delivery of the visit itself. Someone who knew the patient, scheduled the service or handled the bill could recognize a different part of that mismatch. The alleged payment problem extended beyond the hospital’s coding department into care delivered at home.
The later civil resolution addressed hospital cost reporting, referral payments and other billing practices. The June announcement described nearly $620 million to resolve eight qui tam cases the government had joined, and another $11 million for separate billing allegations.
The civil settlements reached different parts of the hospital business. The cost-report allegations followed expenses onto reimbursement paperwork. The kickback allegations followed payments to physicians and the patient referrals those payments allegedly bought.
HCA agreed to pay $356 million to resolve whistleblower allegations involving hospital cost reports. The settlement also addressed cost-report fraud allegations pursued separately by two of the whistleblowers.
A hospital cost report reconciles payments received during the year with the amount the hospital says the government actually owes. It is a claim for government reimbursement at year end. The Justice Department alleged that HCA used those reports in schemes to defraud Medicare, Medicaid and TRICARE.
The June announcement also reported a completed criminal plea: Columbia Management Companies pleaded guilty in 2001 to making false statements in Medicare cost reports. That plea included a charge concerning wound care center costs.
That payment mechanism gives reimbursement staff a different view from someone handling individual patient bills. A cost allocation can affect the hospital’s claim even when it sits far from a patient’s chart. What an expense paid for, where the hospital assigned it and how it reached the cost report are the useful connections.
The referral allegations accounted for $225.5 million. The government alleged that HCA hospitals and home health agencies billed Medicare, Medicaid and TRICARE for claims generated by kickbacks and other payments to physicians in exchange for patient referrals. The December criminal plea agreement also called for Columbia Homecare Group to plead guilty to conspiring to pay kickbacks and other monetary benefits to doctors.
The civil allegation connected a financial arrangement to the patients who arrived and then to the bills sent to the programs. That is why physician-contracting knowledge can matter alongside billing knowledge. Someone who understands the purpose of a payment may explain a relationship that the resulting patient claim does not show.
The injury reaches beyond the bill. The government described payments that compromised the medical judgment patients and health programs relied on.
HCA agreed to pay $17 million over allegations that certain hospitals billed Medicare for unallowable costs of a contractor operating HCA wound care centers and for a noncovered drug the contractor made and sold to patients. The wound care management contractor, Curative Healthcare Services, had previously paid $16.5 million to resolve related allegations. Its role makes the payment chain concrete: an outside contractor operated the center and supplied the drug, while the hospital allegedly billed Medicare. The contractor’s charges and the hospital’s reimbursement claims were parts of the same business relationship.
HCA also agreed to pay $5 million over allegations that it claimed excessive costs when transferring patients to other facilities. The settlement also addressed allegations that Lawnwood Regional Medical Center in Fort Pierce, Florida inflated its entitlement to Medicare funds for treating indigent patients and shifted employee salary costs to increase reimbursement.
Other allegations concerned HCA improperly shifting home office costs to hospitals. Each allegation concerned where a cost belonged or how much the program should pay for it. For an accountant or reimbursement manager, the telling detail may be an allocation decision rather than a false entry in a clinical chart.
HCA’s administrative agreement with the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services required a separate $250 million payment. It resolved claims the company and the agency maintained against each other over hospital cost reports and home office cost statements for reporting periods ending July 31, 2001.
A separate HCA agreement provided $1.5 million to resolve allegations that West Paces Medical Center in Atlanta paid kickbacks for diabetes-patient referrals. A former employee of Diabetes Treatment Centers of America, another defendant, pursued that whistleblower case after the United States declined to join.
That is a concrete example of a whistleblower case continuing after the government’s decision. The employee’s position was with a business involved in the arrangement, giving this case a different origin from an HCA employee reporting hospital billing.
Whistleblowers brought many of the civil issues resolved in the earlier agreement and the lawsuits described in the later announcement. The June release identified a physician, former HCA employees, a former HCA nurse, a former financial officer and a wound care reimbursement manager among the people sharing in the outcome.
Those roles matter to who can bring useful information forward. Clinical work, financial reporting and contracting expose different parts of the same payment system. HCA’s resolutions show why a hospital fraud case can involve knowledge from more than one department and more than one business.
The Congressional Research Service’s 2009 report, Qui Tam: The False Claims Act and Related Federal Statutes, describes the recovery incentive for people who sue in the government’s name. Its historical account explains that Congress strengthened those incentives in 1986 in response to extensive fraud against the United States.
A whistleblower case under the False Claims Act can pay 15% to 30% of what the government recovers. The June announcement specified a combined whistleblower share of about $151.6 million across the cases.
The useful evidence connects the business decision to the government claim. In these allegations, a laboratory order connects to a test bill, a diagnosis connects to reimbursement, a purchase price becomes a management fee, or a physician payment connects to referred patients. An insider can explain why the description on the claim differs from what the business actually did.
Knowledge matters alongside the paperwork: who understood the expense, who chose the coding or allocation, and what the company understood when it submitted the claim. We work with the person who can explain those decisions and connect them to particular payments.
The corporate integrity agreement announced in December 2000 addressed the same operating areas: inpatient coding, laboratory and hospital outpatient billing, and financial relationships with physicians. A coded diagnosis, an expense category and a referral arrangement each have people behind them who understand how the decision was made.
If you can explain the diagnosis, cost allocation or referral payment behind a hospital’s bill, speak with our healthcare fraud whistleblower experts. We work with you to build your strongest hospital fraud whistleblower case, bring in whistleblower lawyers who know hospital reimbursement and stay beside you through the decisions that follow.