Alabama Physician Files Duplicate Claims for Maximum Reimbursement

False Claims Act , Healthcare Fraud

A $1.4 million settlement ended a year-long suit which alleged that an Alabama physician repeatedly filed false claims to Medicaid, Medicare, and TRICARE, often for procedures that were medically unnecessary. James Crumb, the Mobile-based practitioner who specialized in Mobility Metabolism and Wellness, was found to have filed up to thirty identical false claims for a singular patient visit – a practice that required deliberate manipulation of billing codes in order to dupe the initiative put in place to prevent just that.

The National Correct Coding Initiative (NCCI) was designed with the intention to prevent fraudulent or unnecessary claims from being processed simply by analyzing the codes that are submitted by facilities seeking reimbursement. The program detects a number of “red flags” that indicate a claim is not eligible for payment, including when multiple claims are filed for the same procedure; this methodology was apparently well-known by the staff at the facility in question, as they purposefully miscoded procedures as “ultrasound guidance” claims, which are an exception to this rule, in order to file duplicates and receive maximum potential reimbursement.

Although they filed these claims as such, the true nature of the treatments performed were far from medically necessary – among the most absurd, Botox injections. Knowing these would not be reimbursed by government-funded healthcare of any kind, the physician in question would certify that the patients had rare neurological diseases that could only be treated with “trigger point injections,” then manipulating the records to reflect the false diagnoses in order to bilk the programs.

Once establishing that he was able to bypass the NCCI safeguards, Crumb continued on to forge documents outlining the amount of Botox his patients required and consequently received extravagant amounts of the drug. Once the Alabama Medicaid Agency approved and paid for these inflated doses, it was discovered that Crumb did not actually administer them to the patients to which they were prescribed.

In his settlement, Crumb consented to take part in a Corporate Integrity Agreement, during which the Office of the Inspector General is permitted to regularly audit and observe his practices to ensure he is compliant with all federal healthcare regulations. In addition, he is bound into a three-year contract that requires all claims submitted by his practice undergo independent review.

Whistleblower Justice Network Can Help You

Whistleblower Justice Network partners with whistleblowers who seek to bring those to justice who employ deceitful tactics to defraud government healthcare programs. To do so, we couple our extensive knowledge of the False Claims Act with the information brought forward to us by those who see something wrong and choose to do the right thing.

If you have meaningful information regarding healthcare fraud that you believe is in violation of the False Claims Act, Whistleblower Justice Network can help. Working alongside world-class legal counsel, we will ensure you are protected to the fullest extent of the law and that you receive credit for the information you bring to the U.S. government. Partnering with whistleblowers is all we do. Visit us at, or call us at 844-WJN-4ALL.


Related Newsroom Content

  • Registered Nurse Defrauds Medicare for $17M in Home Healthcare Scheme

     A registered nurse based out of Texas was found to have utilized two separate home healthcare clinics to swindle the federal Medicare program for $17 million over the course of the seven-year scheme. The nurse, a resident of Fort Bend, Texas, owned and operated Preferred Health Services Inc. and Deligent Health Services Inc., both based […]

  • Texas Doctor Bilks Medicare for Nearly $400 Million in Large-Scale Fraud, Forgery Scheme

    In an exceptionally heinous example of home healthcare fraud, seven doctors have been apprehended for their roles in a conspiracy to defraud both Medicare and Medicaid alike. Altogether, they have been ordered to pay over $342 million in restitution to recover the money bilked by the extensive false claims submitted over the course of the […]

  • Brooklyn Clinic “Employs” Homeless in $70M Medicare Fraud Scheme

    As if Medicaid fraud didn’t already victimize the nation’s most needy and impoverished individuals as it is, the now-former owner of a Brooklyn-based healthcare clinic figured out how to further abuse these individuals in the pursuit of lining his own pockets. Over the course of nine years, Victor Lipkin and eight others would recruit and […]