Providence Hospice: A Director’s Pay and Another Physician’s Name

Whistleblower Justice Network

The former owner of Providence Hospice and Providence Home Health agreed to pay $1.05 million to resolve allegations of medical-director payments for referrals and Medicare claims that misidentified an attending physician. One allegation concerned what a physician was paid to bring in. The other concerned a different physician whose name appeared on claims for patients he had not served. Someone inside the business could see those decisions in the contracts, referral records and billing instructions. When referrals are bought, taxpayers fund the claims and honest providers lose business to the payments.

Two former employees brought the whistleblower lawsuit behind this hospice fraud case. In its December 10, 2020 announcement, the Justice Department said the former owner had owned both businesses during the alleged conduct and later sold them. The Department of Health and Human Services’ Office of Inspector General placed the former owner in Sugar Land, Texas.

Do Doctors Get Kickbacks for Referrals?

Yes. Paid medical-director positions can disguise referral kickbacks. Here, the government alleged that the owner paid a physician more than fair market value over two years to induce Medicare home-health and hospice referrals. The Office of Inspector General also alleged that the owner submitted Medicare claims associated with those referrals.

The referral-kickback allegation puts the compensation beside the work. We compare the director’s agreement, duties and time records with the valuation supporting the pay and the referrals that followed. The business’s explanation for choosing that physician matters too. A title on a contract can obscure what management actually wanted to buy.

Hospice’s payment structure explains why that referral channel matters. As MedPAC’s March 2026 report describes, routine hospice care pays by the enrolled day, including days without a visit. A referral that becomes an admission opens a continuing payment relationship. Paying for access to patients can therefore shape who gets the Medicare business before a biller submits the first claim.

A separate whistleblower complaint against Odyssey Healthcare described what management allegedly expected from its medical directors:

All of the Medical Directors were required to participate in marketing initiatives, required to visit facilities and build relationships, and required to report their marketing efforts each quarter and also as part of every yearly evaluation.

Whistleblower’s allegation, United States of America ex rel. Bryan Dingus v. Odyssey Healthcare, Inc., complaint, paragraph 56

An evaluation measuring marketing effort gives an insider something concrete to connect to the contract and the compensation. It shows the business purpose alleged in that complaint, beyond the job title.

Medicare Claims Allegedly Named a Physician Who Had Not Provided Care

The government separately alleged that the owner submitted Medicare claims naming another physician as attending even though he had provided no services to the patients. The Justice Department placed those claims between April 1 and September 30, 2016. His medical license was suspended on April 12, 2016. The alleged claims continued after the named physician’s license was suspended.

The OIG notice distinguishes this physician from the physician allegedly paid for referrals. The referral-payment allegation concerns how patients reached the businesses. The attending-physician allegation concerns what the businesses told Medicare about their care.

If you work with Medicare billing records, you may know whose name went on the claim and whether the patient’s records support it. A physician’s name can travel from an internal record into a payment request. The people who maintain those records may know where the name came from and why it stayed there.

What Are the Responsibilities of a Hospice Medical Director?

A hospice medical director’s clinical responsibilities include certifying a patient’s terminal prognosis and recertifying continued eligibility. Medicare’s hospice coverage manual describes certification based on the physician’s clinical judgment, supported by the patient’s circumstances. At the first certification, the attending physician has a role alongside the hospice physician. The hospice physician handles later recertifications. These are clinical decisions about the patient, not just names to enter on a form.

Here, we would compare the service dates and physician entry on each claim with the licensing timeline and what staff knew when they submitted it.

The Owner Also Accepted Exclusion

The former owner agreed to a five-year exclusion from federal health care programs, effective December 8, 2020.

The businesses had changed hands, but the announced payment agreement and exclusion concerned their former owner.

What the Payment and Claim Records Can Show

A medical-director agreement, the actual work and the referral pattern can reveal different accounts of why the business paid a physician. We connect those records with payment approvals and management’s explanations. For the attending-physician allegation, we examine the claim entry alongside the service documentation, licensing dates and instructions to the billing staff.

There is a broader reason to examine the referral pattern. The National Bureau of Economic Research’s 2026 working paper Medicare Home Health Fraud: How Much, Where, and Who? used agencies prosecuted by federal strike forces to build its model. It found that agencies it classified as fraudulent were more likely to rely on extremely high-volume referring physicians. That home-health finding gives context to the business relationship: who sends the patients can help explain how the agency gets its revenue.

The former employees who brought this case shared a whistleblower award. Their case connected knowledge inside the businesses to the former owner’s settlement agreement. A whistleblower case under the False Claims Act can pay 15% to 30% of what the government recovers.

You Know What the Physician Was Paid to Do

If you saw referral expectations behind a director’s pay or a physician’s name on claims for care they never provided, speak to one of our whistleblower experts. We build your strongest hospice whistleblower case around the payments, patient records and decisions you know. We bring in hospice fraud whistleblower lawyers who understand physician arrangements and stay beside you through the case.

WHISTLEBLOWER JUSTICE NETWORK CAN HELP YOU
Make a difference.
Whistleblower Justice NetworkReport Fraud
100% CONFIDENTIALFREE CONSULTATION24 / 7 / 365