ACO Quality Reporting: The Survey Behind the Shared Savings

Whistleblower Justice Network

ACO quality reporting uses patient-survey data to help determine shared savings payments. When someone knowingly submits survey data as corrected while leaving the problem in place, Medicare can pay on a false account of patients’ care. If you prepare those surveys, manage a vendor or review corrections, you may know whether the report reflects what patients actually answered.

Accountable care organizations bring doctors, hospitals and other providers together to coordinate care. Under the Shared Savings Program described in the federal audit, Medicare continued paying providers for their services, while an ACO could earn shared savings by reducing costs and meeting quality standards. Patient experience was part of that quality assessment. The survey had money behind it.

What Patient Surveys Add to ACO Quality Reporting

Patient surveys tell Medicare about experiences that a paid claim cannot describe, such as whether someone could get an appointment or reach a specialist. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services’ performance-year 2022 data dictionary lists CAHPS for MIPS measures covering timely care, communication, access to specialists, shared decision-making and care coordination.

In the performance-year 2017 process examined by the Department of Health and Human Services’ Office of Inspector General, each ACO selected a CMS-certified survey vendor. The vendor mailed questionnaires to a sample of assigned beneficiaries, followed up by telephone with those who had not responded, and reported the data on the ACO’s behalf. The ACO, survey vendor and CMS monitoring contractor had different parts of this healthcare reporting process.

What the 2017 Monitoring Audit Found

The Inspector General’s September 2020 audit found that CMS generally monitored claims, administrative data and Web Interface reporting effectively. Its concerns centered on patient-survey oversight: corrections went unverified, written feedback arrived late, and translated questionnaires escaped review. The auditors tied those weaknesses to the risk of incomplete or inaccurate data affecting quality scores and shared savings payments.

The Checklist Nobody Requested

The monitoring contractor asked a survey vendor to create a checklist documenting its data preparation before submitting survey data to the contractor. The audit described what happened next:

The vendor responded that it had created such a checklist and provided a description of the checklist, but the contractor did not request a copy of the checklist to verify the data preparation activities and to ensure that the vendor submits complete and accurate data.

HHS Office of Inspector General, audit of ACO quality-data monitoring, September 2020

We expect verification to mean more than taking a vendor’s word for it. In the following year’s telephone review, most of the earlier issues, including the checklist issue, still went unverified. We want to know what happened between a promise to correct the process and the next submission that relied on it.

Feedback Arrived After Approval

The contractor delivered written findings after it had approved the quality assurance plans meant to address them. Vendors’ plans were due in May 2018 and approved in June, but the feedback reports arrived in late July. Although the contractor had discussed its findings with vendors earlier, the approved plans did not always include all the changes made to address the identified problems.

The paperwork meant to show that problems had been addressed won approval before the written findings arrived. For someone inside that review, the approval and feedback dates can help explain what the reviewer actually had in hand when signing off.

A Patient Caught the Repeated Question

A Mandarin questionnaire repeated a question, and a beneficiary noticed the error and called the survey vendor. The contractor had updated the translation without checking the questions before posting the template. CMS instructed the monitoring contractor to correct the error, which required a survey vendor to make additional calls to collect missing data for 314 beneficiaries. The missing answer had to come from patients, beyond correcting the wording on the form.

CMS Changed the Contract

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services agreed with the Inspector General’s recommendations to verify corrections, ensure quality assurance plans included implemented changes before approval, and check translated survey materials against the English versions. The fiscal-year 2020 Health Care Fraud and Abuse Control report records a contract modification effective November 23, 2020, incorporating the recommendations.

What We Look for in a Claimed Correction

When we review a claimed survey correction with you, we connect the original problem to the revised work and the data ultimately submitted. The questionnaire and translation show what patients were asked. Collection records and follow-up calls show what answers were obtained. The preparation checklist, feedback report and revised quality assurance plan show what the vendor and reviewer said they checked.

In Medicare fraud cases, the original and corrected submission versions connect that work to the report. Dates, authors and responses to warnings help explain who knew about a discrepancy and what they did with it. This is the same need for corroboration that runs through Medicare fraud detection: the reported result needs the business records behind it.

Medicare and the ACA: Fraud Control Efforts and Results, published in the Business and Health Administration Association’s 2017 conference proceedings, described continuous quality control and internal monitoring as part of ACO integrity. Applied to a survey correction, that means looking beyond the plan’s language to the work that carried it out. An insider can explain why the approved version and the submitted version differ.

When Survey Reporting Changes the Payment

Under the 2022 CMS dictionary’s payment definitions, an ACO had to meet the quality performance standard as well as the savings requirement to earn a shared savings payment. Quality performance also affected the final sharing rate according to the ACO’s track. The amount saved was not simply the amount Medicare paid the ACO.

For 2022, an ACO reporting through both the CMS Web Interface and electronic or MIPS clinical quality measures received the higher-scoring option for its payment calculation. Tying a survey problem to that year’s score and payment is work we do with you.

In a qui tam case, we examine the records connecting the submission to government money, along with what the people responsible knew. The False Claims Act reaches knowingly false claims and false records that matter to payment. A whistleblower case under the False Claims Act can pay 15% to 30% of what the government recovers.

When You Know What Happened to the Survey

If you know a survey correction was claimed but the data sent to Medicare still carried the problem, speak with our whistleblower experts about the submission and who approved it. We work with you to connect the survey process, the decisions inside the business and the shared savings payment, and bring in Medicare fraud whistleblower lawyers who know shared savings and quality-reporting cases. You have a partner through the case, from understanding what you saw to pursuing the government money at stake.

WHISTLEBLOWER JUSTICE NETWORK CAN HELP YOU
Make a difference.
Whistleblower Justice NetworkReport Fraud
100% CONFIDENTIALFREE CONSULTATION24 / 7 / 365